Calculating Sun's G-Force: Anomaly Effects Explained

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Astronomer107
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    G-force
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the gravitational force (g-force) of the Sun and its implications for understanding gravitational anomalies, particularly in relation to black holes and gravitational wave propagation. Participants explore the application of Newton's law of gravitation and the necessary parameters for accurate calculations.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant attempts to calculate the g-force of the Sun using Newton's equation but questions the validity of their result, suggesting they may have miscalculated the radius.
  • Another participant clarifies that the formula for gravitational force should include mass and questions the radius value used in the calculation.
  • A different participant suggests that the distance from the center of the Sun must be considered and expresses uncertainty about the applicability of Newtonian equations for black holes.
  • Some participants discuss the need to convert the Sun's radius from kilometers to meters for accurate calculations.
  • One participant asserts that "g-force" is not a scientific term and claims there is no known gravitational anomaly associated with the Sun.
  • Another participant explains that the gravitational force experienced decreases with distance and that the g-force is a function of mass and distance.
  • There is a suggestion that calculating the g-force for a black hole could involve multiplying the Sun's g-force by the number of solar masses, though this is met with skepticism regarding the validity of such an approach.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the validity of the calculations and the concept of g-force, with some agreeing on the need for accurate parameters while others contest the existence of gravitational anomalies related to the Sun. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the correct approach to calculating the g-force and its implications for black holes.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations in the calculations, including the need for proper unit conversions and the consideration of distance from the Sun's center. There is also a lack of consensus on the applicability of Newtonian physics in the context of black holes.

Astronomer107
Messages
31
Reaction score
0
What is the g force (anomaly) of the sun? I tried to calculate this one using Newton's equation. I did this:

[(6.67 * 10^-11)(2 * 10^30)]/(0.7 * 10^6)

Where F = GM/r^2 ( I think), but I got 272244898, which seems really wrong. I can't find it anywhere online and I'm trying to figure out the effect of the anomaly of a black hole on the oscillation of the fabric of spacetime due to gravitational wave propagation. I think the first step is finding the force of the sun, then multiplying that by the number of solar masses that a black hole has to find its effects on the distortion of time, etc. PLEASE let me know if you know the g force or if I am approaching this in a completely wrong manner. Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
First off
F = GMm/r²

GM/r² gives you the acceleration due to gravity. On the surface of the Earth this comes out to about 9.8m/sec² and is called one g.

G-force is usually considered a factor of this. (On the surface of a planet where the acceleration of gravity is 19.6m/sec² we say some one experiences 2 gs.

Second, where did you get the value of .7 x 106 for the radius squared ? ( making the radius 836.66 meters)
 
Originally posted by Janus
First off
F = GMm/r²

GM/r² gives you the acceleration due to gravity. On the surface of the Earth this comes out to about 9.8m/sec² and is called one g.

G-force is usually considered a factor of this. (On the surface of a planet where the acceleration of gravity is 19.6m/sec² we say some one experiences 2 gs.

Second, where did you get the value of .7 x 106 for the radius squared ? ( making the radius 836.66 meters)

I got that value from some website (I knew I should have looked for a better radius). How can I figure out the g of a 10 solar mass black hole? If the sun is a certain "g" then can I multiply it by 10 to get the g of a 10 solar mass black hole?
 
For r u have to use the DISTANCE from the center of the sun...so u would add the radius of the sun to the distance from the sun surface to the Earth's center..

Im not sure if Newtonian equations work for black holes or not..
 
Originally posted by Astronomer107
I got that value from some website (I knew I should have looked for a better radius).
Okay, I think I found your problem, the Sun's radius is 6.95 x 105 kilometers you have to convert this to meters first before plugging it into the formula.
 
Originally posted by Astronomer107
If the sun is a certain "g" then can I multiply it by 10 to get the g of a 10 solar mass black hole?

The 'g' depends on where you are looking. It decreases as your distance gets farther away.
 
Originally posted by Astronomer107
What is the g force (anomaly) of the sun?

There is none. "g-force" does not exist in science, it is a brand name of some PC videocards.

Nor does Sun have any known gravitational anomaly.

I tried to calculate this one using Newton's equation. I did this:

[(6.67 * 10^-11)(2 * 10^30)]/(0.7 * 10^6)

Where F = GM/r^2 ( I think), but I got 272244898, which seems really wrong.

I guess you tried to calculate acceleration of gravity of Sun near Sun's surface using Newtonian formula, but forgot to convert Sun's radius into meters and to square it (gravitation obeys inverse square law). Doing arithmetic a little more accurate, you would get 272 m/s2 which is about 28 times the acceleration of gravity of Earth (near Earth surface).

If you plug into denominator the distance between Earth and Sun, you'll get acceleration of gravity of Sun near Earth 0.0059 m/s2. Multiplying this by Earth mass 6x1024 kg you'll get weight of Earth 3.6x1022 N in gravitational field of Sun (the force with which Sun attracts Earth).

Alternatively, you can calculate Earth gravitational field in the vicinity of Sun plugging into above formula Earth mass and Earth-Sun distance (and you'll find that gravitational field of Earth is about 0.00000018 m/s2 strong in Sun's neighborhood), and then you can calculate Sun's weight in this gravitational field of Earth: w = mg = 3.6x1022 N (which is the force with which Earth attracts Sun).

I can't find it anywhere online and I'm trying to figure out the effect of the anomaly of a black hole on the oscillation of the fabric of spacetime due to gravitational wave propagation .

Don't worry about that much. This is incoherent set of words (which separately do have scientific meaning however). Try to use other combinations (and permutations) of them - one day you may get lucky and have more meaningful sentence, though it may take some time (because there are about 10 terms here if not to count prepositions, and 10! is a big number).

I think the first step is finding the force of the sun, then multiplying that by the number of solar masses that a black hole has to find its effects on the distortion of time, etc. PLEASE let me know if you know the g force or if I am approaching this in a completely wrong manner. Thanks!

I think first step is to practice more in arithmetic, second - to learn some algebra, third - to learn some basic physics (concepts of acceleration, of mass, of force, etc), forth - to learn Newtonian law of gravitation, forth - to learn calculus and more physics, fifth - to learn learn tensor calculus, sixths - to learn some General Relativity. Only then IMO you will be able to at least find a right combination of such terms as black hole, gravitational wave and gravitational anomaly. (Before that - beware of 10!, it is a big number).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Originally posted by enigma
The 'g' depends on where you are looking. It decreases as your distance gets farther away.

But for a constant distance, yes, G is a multiple of the mass.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 43 ·
2
Replies
43
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
15K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
7K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 0 ·
Replies
0
Views
4K
  • · Replies 83 ·
3
Replies
83
Views
16K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K