Physics Forums (http://www.physicsforums.com/index.php)
-   General Physics (http://www.physicsforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=111)
-   -   I violate law of energy conservation (http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=245486)

 atom888 Jul17-08 11:33 AM

I violate law of energy conservation

Let's say we have a helium balloon carrying total weight of 1 kg.
We set up 2 stations. Pumping station on the ground and deflating station at certain height.
We pump the ballon until it start to float up. We catch it at deflating station at height H.
Now the energy we gain is potential energy of the falling balloon which is mGH.
The energy require for pumping and deflating a ballon is set! If any.
The height H can stretch as high as you want to! => mGH is a linear increasing function.

 berkeman Jul17-08 11:47 AM

Re: I violate law of energy conservation

Cool -- perpetual motion finally!

But seriously, if this is a closed cycle that runs continuously, how do you get the helium back down to the ground to keep refilling the balloon....? Pump it, right? And the energy you could get out of the balloon motion gets used up (plus more) in the helium pumping.

Oh well, still no perpetual motion.

 atom888 Jul17-08 11:20 PM

Re: I violate law of energy conservation

Well, there's no problem in getting the helium back down. Just make a sealed tube that contain air lighter than helium and let gravity do the work. Yeah, still the sticky point is the pumping the ballon part. I suspect the energy require to pump the ballon is theoratically exact as the maximum height the ballon would reach. Oh well, I'll find another way to break that law.

 russ_watters Jul17-08 11:42 PM

Re: I violate law of energy conservation

Quote:
 Quote by atom888 (Post 1805325) Oh well, I'll find another way to break that law.
Your time really would be better spent on another pursuit. Right now, you're playing a lottery with no jackpot!

 ZapperZ Jul18-08 04:13 AM

Re: I violate law of energy conservation

I think we have entertained this sufficiently. Please review the PF Guidelines on why such topic of discussion is not allowed on here.

Zz.

 All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:43 AM.