Physics Forums (http://www.physicsforums.com/index.php)
-   Introductory Physics Homework (http://www.physicsforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=153)
-   -   Special Relativity. How to use the Lorentz Transformation? (http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=584455)

 AlonsoMcLaren Mar6-12 04:03 PM

Special Relativity. How to use the Lorentz Transformation?

γ1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

Stan is at rest on the Earth while Mary is moving away from the Earth at a constant speed
of 0.600c. Stan and Mary start their timers when Mary passes Stan (in other words, t = t' = x = x' = 0 at that instant).

(a) When Mary has traveled a distance of 0.900 *108m according to Stan, what is the time according to Stan?

(b) At the instant Stan reads the time calculated in part (a), what does Mary’s timer read?

2. Relevant equations

Lorentz Transformation

3. The attempt at a solution
(a) is simple. I got it correctly. t=x/V=0.5s

I got (b) wrong. I plugged in the Lorentz Transformation:

x=0
γ=1.25
V=0.600c
t=0.5s

t' =γ (t-Vx/c2) = 0.625 s.

But the answer is 0.4s, which claims that x=0.900 *108m, not 0.

However, at the instant Stan reads the time 0.5s from his clock, he and his clock are sitting on the earth, not 0.900 *108m away from earth. So I do not think that x=0.

 Doc Al Mar6-12 05:42 PM

Re: Special Relativity. How to use the Lorentz Transformation?

Quote:
 Quote by AlonsoMcLaren (Post 3801997) However, at the instant Stan reads the time 0.5s from his clock, he and his clock are sitting on the earth, not 0.900 *108m away from earth. So I do not think that x=0.
The question should be interpreted as "At the instant Stan reads the time calculated in part (a), what does Mary’s timer read according to Stan?"

No, x ≠ 0. According to Stan, where is Mary at the moment in question?

 All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:30 PM.