Physics Forums

Physics Forums (http://www.physicsforums.com/index.php)
-   Biology (http://www.physicsforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=82)
-   -   Why can animals swim? (http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=76667)

Bladibla May23-05 06:18 PM

Why can animals swim?
 
How is that most animals, such as dogs or cats, have the basic instinct of knowing how to swim, and we don't?

Why arn't we born with the knowledge of how to swim?

quasi426 May23-05 06:33 PM

In general, if there is no selective pressure to preserve something genetically, for example all those who don't know how to swim will be eaten by a predator, then that genetic information can be filtered out in time.

DocToxyn May23-05 08:45 PM

There is an instinctual, albeit rudimentary, ability of humans to swim that can be observed very early in life. I used to teach young kids how to swim and the very young if submerged will close their mouth and kick in an attempt to swim. They weren't very good at it and it couldn't save their lives, but the skill was recognizable. We as a species have developed the need to acquire a large skill set in order to survive and this is best developed by learning from others. Perhaps the number and complexity of the many tasks we must learn throughout our lives has led to the need to learn these skills, rather than just perform them innately.

matthyaouw May24-05 05:05 AM

I've heard that newborns can swim instinctively. Its often used as evidence for the aquatic ape theory or our origin.

whozum May24-05 05:30 AM

Quote:

Quote by matthyaouw
I've heard that newborns can swim instinctively. Its often used as evidence for the aquatic ape theory or our origin.

I thought that was atributed to their nine month carriage period.

matthyaouw May24-05 05:54 AM

I'm not sure. I'm only what I've read in other places.

LURCH May24-05 01:03 PM

Quote:

Quote by whozum
I thought that was atributed to their nine month carriage period.

Unlikely; swimming does not take place in the womb, nor is it necessary (a fetus who can't swim is in no greater danger of drowning than one who can).

whozum May24-05 08:23 PM

Maybe not swimming, but bouyancy?

Phobos Jun1-05 11:00 AM

I think animals, including humans, have a survival instinct. Therefore, toss a land animal into the water and it will try to keep its head above water and propel itself back to shore. Its success will depend on its buoyancy, anatomy, etc. An adult human will try this too (provided he/she doesn't completely panic) and "dog paddle" back to shore. The thing about babies is that they are not as fully developed as many other land animals are upon birth (a likely consequence of our emphasis on brain development). Consider how babies are largely helpless for months after birth whereas many other animals are on-the-go after a matter of hours or days. I'm not sure a newborn dog/cat could do much better (please don't try this experiment!).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© 2014 Physics Forums