prove that of sum square root of 2 and square root of 3 is not rational


by transgalactic
Tags: prove, rational, root, square
transgalactic
transgalactic is offline
#1
Nov22-08, 12:27 AM
P: 1,399
prove that the square root of 2 plus the square root of 3 is not rational?

does always the sum of two not rational numbers is a not rational number?



i know the proof 2 = a^2/b^2
i separately proved that square root of 2 and square root of 3 are irrational

how two prove that the sum of two such numbers is irrational too?

whats the formal equation proof?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
NASA's space station Robonaut finally getting legs
Free the seed: OSSI nurtures growing plants without patent barriers
Going nuts? Turkey looks to pistachios to heat new eco-city
Mark44
Mark44 is online now
#2
Nov22-08, 12:38 AM
Mentor
P: 21,024
Quote Quote by transgalactic View Post
prove that the square root of 2 plus the square root of 3 is not rational?

does always the sum of two not rational numbers is a not rational number?



i know the proof 2 = a^2/b^2
i separately proved that square root of 2 and square root of 3 are irrational

how two prove that the sum of two such numbers is irrational too?

whats the formal equation proof?
Try a proof by contradiction. Suppose that [tex]\sqrt{2} + \sqrt{3} = \frac{a}{b}[/tex]
where a and b are integers with no common factors.

For your second question [tex]\sqrt{5} + (-\sqrt{5}) = 0 [/tex]
Those are both irrational numbers, but their sum is rational.
nicksauce
nicksauce is offline
#3
Nov22-08, 12:47 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
nicksauce's Avatar
P: 1,276
Well clearly two irrational numbers can sum to give a rational number. For example (2+sqrt(2)) + (2 -sqrt(2)).

To show that the sqrt(2) + sqrt(3) is irrational, you can start with
a = sqrt(2) + sqrt(3)
Manipulate to get
a^4 - 10a^2 + 1 = 0

Then you can use the rational roots theorem, that shows that the only rational roots of this equation can be +- 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_root_theorem

Chaos2009
Chaos2009 is offline
#4
Nov22-08, 12:48 AM
P: 81

prove that of sum square root of 2 and square root of 3 is not rational


Quote Quote by Mark44 View Post
For your second question [tex]\sqrt{5} + (-\sqrt{5}) = 0 [/tex]
Those are both irrational numbers, but their sum is rational.
Somehow, that just seems like cheating, but it does fit the problem we were given.
nicksauce
nicksauce is offline
#5
Nov22-08, 12:50 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
nicksauce's Avatar
P: 1,276
Quote Quote by Chaos2009 View Post
Somehow, that just seems like cheating, but it does fit the problem we were given.
Any mathematical statement can be disproved by a counterexample. The simpler the counterexample, the better.
transgalactic
transgalactic is offline
#6
Nov22-08, 01:31 AM
P: 1,399
ok i will try to prove by contradiction:
suppose
(2)^0.5 + (3)^0.5 is a rational number
(if we multiply a rational number by a rational number we will get a rational number "h")
5+2*(2)^0.5 * (3)^0.5=h
24=h^2 -10*h +25

h^2 -10*h +1=0
what to do now?
nicksauce
nicksauce is offline
#7
Nov22-08, 01:55 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
nicksauce's Avatar
P: 1,276
As I suggested earlier, make use of the rational roots theorem.
transgalactic
transgalactic is offline
#8
Nov22-08, 02:11 AM
P: 1,399
by this rational roots theorem
the possible roots is +1 and -1

not one of the represent the actual roots of h^2 -10*h +1=0

what is the next step in the prove?
Mark44
Mark44 is online now
#9
Nov22-08, 05:19 PM
Mentor
P: 21,024
What did you set out to do in your post #6?
Quantumpencil
Quantumpencil is offline
#10
Nov22-08, 07:34 PM
P: 96
You don't need anything but parity to prove this.

Prove



[tex]\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{3} = (p/q)[/tex]
[tex]2 \sqrt{6}+5 = p^{2}/q^{2}[/tex]

You know that the rationals form a field, which implies all the terms in the sum must be a rational.

Now all that remains is to show [tex]\sqrt{6}[/tex] is irrational. So just show that if it equals p/q, p and q must both be even.
transgalactic
transgalactic is offline
#11
Nov23-08, 12:52 AM
P: 1,399
Quote Quote by transgalactic View Post
ok i will try to prove by contradiction:
suppose
(2)^0.5 + (3)^0.5 is a rational number
(if we multiply a rational number by a rational number we will get a rational number "h")
5+2*(2)^0.5 * (3)^0.5=h
24=h^2 -10*h +25

h^2 -10*h +1=0
what to do now?
the root test showed me that there is no rational roots for this equation.
is it fair to consider "h" irrational because of it?

i was told that if we dont have a rational roots it doesnt mean that
"h" is always irrational,"h" could be a complex number.

??
Mark44
Mark44 is online now
#12
Nov23-08, 12:59 AM
Mentor
P: 21,024
If a number is complex, it certainly isn't a rational number. If h^2 - 10h + 1 = 0 doesn't have any rational roots, then there is no solution for h that is rational.
transgalactic
transgalactic is offline
#13
Nov23-08, 01:07 AM
P: 1,399
you meant "irrational" (in the end) right?
Mark44
Mark44 is online now
#14
Nov23-08, 01:16 AM
Mentor
P: 21,024
I edited my reply. The last part should have said "there is no solution that is rational."
jay17
jay17 is offline
#15
Jun22-09, 02:12 AM
P: 1
Quote Quote by nicksauce View Post
Well clearly two irrational numbers can sum to give a rational number. For example (2+sqrt(2)) + (2 -sqrt(2)).

To show that the sqrt(2) + sqrt(3) is irrational, you can start with
a = sqrt(2) + sqrt(3)
Manipulate to get
a^4 - 10a^2 + 1 = 0

Then you can use the rational roots theorem, that shows that the only rational roots of this equation can be +- 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_root_theorem
how did you arrive at a^4 - 10a^2 + 1 = 0?
need help
Mentallic
Mentallic is offline
#16
Jun22-09, 05:43 AM
HW Helper
P: 3,436
Well since we've already summoned this thread from the grave...
Quote Quote by jay17 View Post
how did you arrive at a^4 - 10a^2 + 1 = 0?
need help
[tex]a=\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{3}[/tex]

[tex]a^2=(\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{3})^2=2+2\sqrt{2}\sqrt{3}+3=5+2\sqrt{6}[/tex]

[tex](a^2-5)^2=(2\sqrt{6})^2[/tex]

[tex]a^4-10a^2+25=24[/tex]

[tex]a^4-10a^2+1=0[/tex]


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Proove that the cubic root of 2 + the square root of 2 is irrational Calculus & Beyond Homework 4
Square Root General Math 14
prove that the square root of 3 is not rational Calculus & Beyond Homework 2
Prove the Square Root of 2 is irrational Introductory Physics Homework 4
Square root of 3? Brain Teasers 8