image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Other Sciences > Chemistry


Reply

image electronegativity difference NaH Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Nov2-09, 11:26 AM                  #1
Radwa Kamal

Radwa Kamal is Offline:
Posts: 11
electronegativity difference NaH

Although the electronegativity difference between sodium and hydrogen in NaH is less than 1.7 , it is ionic bond WHY??
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov2-09, 01:20 PM                  #2
chemisttree
 
chemisttree's Avatar

chemisttree is Offline:
Posts: 2,302
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Who told you it was ionic?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov2-09, 03:16 PM                  #3
Radwa Kamal

Radwa Kamal is Offline:
Posts: 11
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Any alkaline metal hydride is ionic

Ionic hydrides
Ionic or saline hydride, is a hydrogen atom bound to an extremely electropositive metal, generally an alkali metals or alkaline earth metals.
source:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydride#Ionic_hydrides
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov2-09, 04:04 PM                  #4
chemisttree
 
chemisttree's Avatar

chemisttree is Offline:
Posts: 2,302
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Do you think it is purely ionic or might it have a bit of covalent character to it?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov2-09, 11:20 PM       Last edited by Radwa Kamal; Nov3-09 at 06:59 AM..            #5
Radwa Kamal

Radwa Kamal is Offline:
Posts: 11
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

I think it is purely ionic because for metals with weak metallic bond like alkaline metals it's a must to lose its valence electron completely for them they are are rarely found in covalent compounds.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov3-09, 10:46 AM                  #6
alxm

alxm is Offline:
Posts: 699
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Bah, everything's got a bit of a covalent character to it and vice-versa :) Do the actual QM calculations and you won't find nice integers popping up very often..
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov3-09, 05:03 PM                  #7
Radwa Kamal

Radwa Kamal is Offline:
Posts: 11
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited cuz am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov4-09, 05:04 AM                  #8
nimmysnv

nimmysnv is Offline:
Posts: 17
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Originally Posted by Radwa Kamal View Post
Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited cuz am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations
Hi,

This is the same as, I have heard about as, this is what I have studied in my time.

Thanks!
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov4-09, 04:57 PM                  #9
chemisttree
 
chemisttree's Avatar

chemisttree is Offline:
Posts: 2,302
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Originally Posted by Radwa Kamal View Post
Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited cuz am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations
With an electronegativity difference of only 1.7 it is likely a very polarized covalent bond or an very covalent ionic bond. Semantics.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov6-09, 11:12 AM                  #10
pseudophonist

pseudophonist is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

The only way I can tell to distinguish the two cases is on a macroscopic level. Lets face it, on a quantum level there's basically no straightforward way of telling ionic from covalent. (all the atoms are in a lattice and there's electrons everywhere)
So, if you hit a large crystal of NaH with a hammer, would it shatter? if you melt NaH (in an inert atmosphere), will it conduct electricity?
My gut says yes to both, and therefore I would say NaH is ionic.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov8-09, 01:06 AM                  #11
ranadeep

ranadeep is Offline:
Posts: 2
Re: electronegativity difference NaH

Yea its a Ionic Compound ( due to its properties) with more Covalent Character : )
We know nothing is Purely(100%) ionic or covalent : )
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply

Tags
difference, electronegativity, nah
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: electronegativity difference NaH
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
chemistry- electronegativity and bonding Dell Other Sciences 1 Mar19-09 05:23 PM
[SOLVED] Electronegativity Confusion MichaelXY Other Sciences 4 Apr21-08 10:44 AM
Electronegativity plstevens Other Sciences 2 Apr1-08 08:31 AM
electronegativity and dipole moments saltyload Chemistry 1 Sep12-07 04:08 AM
Electronegativity scott_alexsk Other Sciences 1 Jan23-06 01:42 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image