Register to reply 
ReissnerNordström repulsion 
Share this thread: 
#1
Mar2111, 08:37 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,597

The googleable literature on the ReissnerNordström repulsion is leaving me confused. This seems to be a contentious topic. I've found the following:
1. Grøn, "Nonexistence of the ReissnerNordström repulsion in general relativity," 1983, "The radial motion of a free neutral test particle in the ReissnerNordström spacetime is studied. It is shown that when the contribution of the electrical field energy to the mass of the central body is properly taken account of, there is no repulsion of the test particle inside the inner horizon of the spacetime." http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1983PhLA...94..424G 2. Qadir, "ReissnerNordstrom repulsion," "It is pointed out that there was an error in the recent paper by Grøn claiming that there is no electrogravitic repulsion in the ReissnerNordstrom geometry. It is concluded that the earlier result of Mahajan, Qadir and Valanju still stands." http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1983PhLA...99..419Q 3. Grøn, "Poincaré stress and the ReissnerNordström repulsion," GRG 20 (1988) 123, " The ReissnerNordström repulsion is shown to be a consequence of Poincaré stresses in a static, charged object. The strong energy condition implies that the ReissnerNordström repulsions do not stop a neutral test particle, falling freely from rest at infinity in the fields of a charged body, before it hits the surface of the body. However, if the particle falls from rest at a sufficiently small height above the surface of the body, it will not reach the surface due to the ReissnerNordström repulsion." 4. "Einstein's general theory of relativity: with modern applications in cosmology," Øyvind Grøn, Sigbjørn Hervik, 2007 [homework problem] "Consider a radially infalling neutral particle in the ReissnerNordström spacetime with M>Q. Show that when the particle comes inside the radius r=Q2/m it will feel a repulsion away from r=0 (i.e. that d2r/dtau2<0 for tau the proper time of the particle). Is this inside or outside the outer horizon r+? Show further that the particle can never reach the singularity at r=0." Unfortunately 13 are not freely accessible online. Are 3 and 4 showing that Grøn has changed his mind (possibly being won over by the arguments in 2)? But the specific statements made in 34 do not clearly contradict the ones made in 1. It's not obvious to me that "repulsion" has a unique definition. The acceleration referred to in 4 is a coordinate acceleration, not a proper acceleration, so it's coordinatedependent. It seems to me that on a general manifold, "repulsion" clearly can't be well defined. E.g., if a body at the north pole of a sphere causes a body at the south pole to accelerate in a certain direction, is that an attraction, or a repulsion? But I suppose it's possible to define "repulsion" in a more unabmiguous way if your spacetime is asymptotically flat...? 


#2
Mar2211, 03:00 AM

P: 203

Not really answering your question directly, but a related discussion which may be useful  namely the apparently repulsive field of a charged mass point is discussed by Pekeris:
http://www.pnas.org/content/79/20/6404.full.pdf 


#3
Mar2211, 11:23 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,597

Ben 


#4
Mar2211, 12:30 PM

P: 203

ReissnerNordström repulsion
Basically he discusses the surprising repulsive force that you get when M=0 in Reissner Nordstrom, then argues that this is unrealistic because with the charge present, there will be always an equivalent electromagnetic mass, consequently the field ends up being attractive ! 


#5
Mar2211, 06:16 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,597

I see, thanks!
But I guess this doesn't say anything about the nonzero mass case. 


#6
Mar2311, 02:40 AM

P: 203

No, I guess it doesn't. It seems to be a restatement of your abstract number 1 above. His abstract states (sorry, the copy from the pdf screws up the mathematical notation, and I'm too lazy to Latex it !) 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Reissner Nordstrom  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
ReissnerNordström metric for magnetic fields  Special & General Relativity  4  
Nordström's second gravitational theory  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
Schwarzschild and Reissner–Nordström metrics...  Astronomy & Astrophysics  2  
The ReissnerNordstrom metric...  Astronomy & Astrophysics  3 