New Reply

0^0 = 1

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Jun17-11, 10:43 AM   #103
 

0^0 = 1


Quote by dimension10 View Post
Means if you put b 1 time you get 1, right?
I think my brain melted...

Quote by disregardthat View Post
What I'm most interested in is what you consider "a number" is.
Quote by micromass View Post
dimension10, what exactly is your definition of a number?
Thirded. I too would like to know.
Jun17-11, 12:45 PM   #104
 
Mentor
Quote by dimension10 View Post
b multiplied by 1 means 1 times of b. Means if you put b 1 time you get 1, right? So, 1 is a number.
No, you get b.
Jun17-11, 01:01 PM   #105
 
Quote by disregardthat View Post
2 is not a prime number. Every other prime number is odd, only 2 stands out.
Doesn't that make 2 rather odd?
Jun17-11, 03:00 PM   #106
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Retired Staff Staff Emeritus
dimension10: you have an opinion on the meaning of the word "number". Your opinion differs from the established usage of the word. That fact will not change no matter how many rationalizations you give.


(moderator hat on) If you wish to continue to try and tell people that they ought to redefine number to match what you want things to be, then do one of the following two things:
  1. Go to another forum
  2. Find a really, strongly compelling reason why such a convention is actually useful

(hint: some minor technical condition you have arbitrarily decided should define "number" does not count as a "compelling reason", especially when lacking motivation)
Jun17-11, 05:21 PM   #107
 
Blog Entries: 8
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Retired Staff Staff Emeritus
dimension 10, what you must realize is that calling something a number doesn't mean that this something suddenly is something magical. It's just another name. That's all it is.

If I would call the integers bazalbieba's, then I could, and everything would still work the same way. But mathematicians have not decided to use the word bazalbieba's, but to use the word number. It's just a name..

I agree that 0 is just a concept, but so are 1,2 and 3. These are all just concepts, which we happen to call "number". Like I said, you can call them something else if you want to, but mathematicians still use the word "number"...

When I call 6 a perfect number, it just means that the sum of it's proper divisors is 6. It means nothing more. It doesn't mean that 6 is suddenly perfection or something. It means exactly what the definition says it means, nothing more and nothing less.

Sorry, Hurk, if a reply wasn't allowed anymore, but I think this could end some confusion.
New Reply
Thread Tools