Spiked Math: MPF  Hatsby Greg Bernhardt Tags: None 

#1
Feb1712, 06:30 PM

Admin
P: 8,536

Today is Math Puzzle Friday (MPF), Yay! Every Friday I'll describe a riddle, game, logic puzzle, etc., that I find interesting and want to share with you. Some of you will surely have heard of the puzzles discussed and may already know the solutions, but to those who haven't, I hope you find them enjoyable! Today's puzzle: Try to make sense of the above comic. Why did they all say damn at the same time? What ARE the odds? Why? How? What? Who? When? Where? Context: Okay fine! I'll provide some context. This is the hats puzzle for three people: "Three people enter the room, each with a hat on their head. There are two colors of hats: red and blue; they are assigned randomly. Each person can see the hats of the two other people, but they can't see their own hats. Each person can either try to guess the color of their own hat or pass. All three do it simultaneously, so there is no way to base their guesses on the guesses of others. If nobody guesses incorrectly and at least one person guesses correctly, they all share a big prize. Otherwise they all lose. Problem 1 (medium): Solve the hats puzzle for three people (i.e., maximize their chance of winning). Problem 2 (hard): Solve the hats puzzle for 2^N  1 people. Recently, hat problems have become a hot topic in mathematics, ever since it was discovered that Hamming codes can be applied to the puzzle (this is a hint for a possible solution to Problem 2). Problem 3 (easier): The following puzzle (submitted by Florian) might be more manageable: "Four dwarfs are buried to the head in sand by some sadistic and cruel man, but he gives them a chance to escape the otherwise inescapable death, if one of them can find out the color of his hat. They are positioned as follows:More... 



#3
Feb2412, 01:21 PM

Admin
P: 22,673

Dwarfs are easy. B sees C&D, and if he doesn't know what the answer is, it means C&D don't have identical hats. So if B doesn't speak, C knows the color of his hat. A&D could be just Poles.




#4
Feb2412, 04:03 PM

PF Gold
P: 11,032

Spiked Math: MPF  Hats
Wait...can the dwarves look around? I thought they all faced the wall, meaning B couldn't see anyone, C sees only B, and D sees both.




#5
Feb2612, 02:39 PM

P: 79





#6
Feb2612, 03:04 PM

Admin
P: 22,673

Sorry, I got them looking in the wrong direction. But the idea is still the same. If the one seeing two doesn't know the answer, the one seeing one knows what to say.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Spiked Math web comic partnership!  Forum Feedback & Announcements  8  
Spiked Math: MFT  Trivial fun  Science Comics  3  
Spiked Math: Adventures with Dr Evilsevier  Science Comics  5  
Spiked Math: The Publishing Process  Science Comics  1  
Spiked Math: The Outer Limits  Science Comics  0 