Register to reply 
What is a number, and what is it made of?by JT73
Tags: number 
Share this thread: 
#1
Nov1812, 12:45 PM

P: 49

In your opinion. Or feel free to quote some people on their views of the answer.



#2
Nov1812, 01:21 PM

P: 772

"Number" doesn't have a definition. It's just a colloquialism.



#3
Nov1812, 03:33 PM

P: 49

And thats why number theory/set theory will be at a standstill until we choose to define it.



#4
Nov1812, 04:03 PM

Mentor
P: 18,299

What is a number, and what is it made of?
What makes you think number theory and set theory is at a standstill?? Are you just making things up? 


#5
Nov1812, 05:24 PM

P: 772

Number theory studies the integers, which are perfectly well defined. It would be hard to imagine a more thriving and successful area of research than modern number theory. 


#6
Nov1812, 07:17 PM

P: 49

I should have said "number theory will progress at an amazing rate, but far slower then it could, should it choose to continue ignoring to define certain terms."



#7
Nov1812, 07:18 PM

Mentor
P: 18,299

And really, if you think one definition is going to progress a field, then you are being pretty naive. Where are you getting your quotes?? 


#8
Nov1812, 07:20 PM

P: 49

I was told a few posts up, number doesn't have a definition. Sorry, care to define it for me?



#9
Nov1812, 07:21 PM

Mentor
P: 18,299




#10
Nov1812, 07:24 PM

P: 49

Thank you for your patience, but If i may..
You are saying that number theory is about the study of integers...which are...numbers? So then it is the study of something which is defined to be a type of "number." Wouldn't it seem plausible then to define number? And may I ask why number doesn't have a definition, then? 


#11
Nov1812, 07:29 PM

Mentor
P: 18,299

You do have things like
All of these things are perfectly welldefined. The word number is just used to give it a common name. In the same way, complex numbers are not really complex and rational numbers are not really rational. 


#12
Nov1812, 07:33 PM

P: 49

"The word number is just used to give it a common name."
Okay, by calling them all "numbers" you are giving them all something in common. You are saying you are only giving them a common name, but are you not also placing them under a common group, mainly being "numbers?" A complex number, though different then a transfinite number falls under the class of both being numbers, no? So then they fall under the collection of both being....what? define that last part, is what I'm asking. 


#13
Nov1812, 07:43 PM

P: 828




#14
Nov1812, 07:46 PM

P: 49

but yet again you are saying "every type of number", and so categorizing it under a certain conception within your mind, namely all being the idea of a number (regardless of being different types) , define that conception if possible. 


#15
Nov1812, 07:49 PM

Mentor
P: 18,299

A number should be something that can be added and multiplied to other numbers and it should in some way be an extension of the natural numbers. That's about all we can say. 


#16
Nov1812, 07:50 PM

P: 828

Perhaps there is no good definition of this general concept. BUT, this does not mean anything about the field of number theory. Again, number theory is the study of integers, so we don't need to give a definition of "number" to study integers.



#17
Nov1812, 07:55 PM

P: 49

Exactly, its a psychological thing. Don't we all conceive of this "variable" in different ways, in a way in which each person conceptualizes it differently, but somehow conceives of it in a general way so that others can also know what one is referring to while talking about this conception? We say "number" for psychological reasons, yes, and what are those reasons? So that whomever is listening can picture the idea within their intellect in a way, specific enough to themselves, that it makes complete sense uniquely to them, but in a way general enough, so that it can be talked of by all. I was curious what your definitions of what this "picture/idea within your intellect" is and how you would describe it. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
[C++] Efficiently counting the number of '1' bits inside blocks of a binary number  Programming & Computer Science  4  
A Number Made Up Of Two Digits  Precalculus Mathematics Homework  19  
What made the universe have 3 dimensions, instead of some other number?  Cosmology  42  
Cells are made of molecules,molecules are made of atoms,atoms are made of energy.so..  Biology  9  
Number of revolutions a disk has made after a given time  Introductory Physics Homework  1 