Do Mice Prefer Being Caught? Exploring Animal Behavior and Emptiness

  • Thread starter Thread starter Emieno
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of "emptiness," exploring its psychological implications and experiences associated with it. Participants delve into the feelings of emptiness in humans, particularly in relation to mental health issues such as depression and suicidal tendencies. The conversation also touches on the philosophical aspects of emptiness and its definitions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Psychological reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants inquire about the nature of emptiness and seek a definition, suggesting that it may relate to feelings of failure and lack of motivation.
  • Others propose that emptiness can be akin to chronic loneliness, where one feels disconnected even in social situations.
  • One participant describes emptiness as a "psych-ache," comparing it to physical hunger, indicating a deep mental discontent.
  • Another perspective suggests that emptiness equates to nothingness, where one cannot feel any emotions, whether positive or negative.
  • A participant shares a personal experience of emptiness linked to meditation, describing it as a profound realization of the lack of substance in existence.
  • Some contributions highlight the relationship between depression and suicidal thoughts, noting that feelings of emptiness may arise in both manic and depressive phases of bipolar disorder.
  • One participant challenges the understanding of emptiness by suggesting that it cannot be defined, as it represents a lack of existence.
  • Another participant references physics, hinting at a potential connection between emptiness and energy at a quantum level.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the nature of emptiness, with no consensus reached on its definition or implications. Some agree on the connection between emptiness and mental health issues, while others dispute the relationship between depression and suicidal behavior.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes various interpretations of emptiness, which may depend on personal experiences and psychological states. The complexity of the topic leads to differing opinions and a lack of clear definitions.

Emieno
Messages
97
Reaction score
0
As usual, mouse is always afraid of cat, that I think is because it is afraid to be eaten. But are there any experiments carried out to check the mouse's brain ?

Second, in human beings, what people usually call "feel the emptiness" is what I really still don't understand. So , how can you describe such a feeling ?
If someone wants to kill himself, but no one helps him to do that, does such a feeling come to exist anyway? Please give me your example too if possible..

Thanks
 
Biology news on Phys.org
I was reading something in my abnormal psych class about the bi-polar people who commit suicide. It is much more likely to happen in the manic phase of the disease than in the depression phase of the disease. In many cases, depressed people may feel the emptiness and desire suicide, but lack the energy to move to action until the manic phase kicks in.
 
But I am looking for a definition of *emptiness*.
 
Well, try it this way. What is it in your life that makes it "full"? What if all of that was suddenly taken from you? Or if if it suddenly became meaningless or seemingly insignificant? To the average person, who hasn't been through a great deal of hardships or trauma or depression, this might be hard to grasp.
 
I agree that some cases of succide commitment come from depression but depression isn't a means that leads people to killing themselves.
If i knew what is *emptiness*, I would not ask you what is *full*. So could you tell me what it is?
 
Can you understand having an empty stomach with nothing to eat? It desires, growls, and aches, with nothing to satisfy it. There is a similar mental malaise sometimes called a "psych-ache". There is a discontent and hunger feeling in a person's "self" - nothing gives pleasure, nothing give satisfaction, and nothing gives contentment. If you are never acquainted with this feeling then you are a fortunate person.
 
well, that sounds familiar but your explanation doesn't show you have any knowledge about reasoning psychologically to how and what things are to go and stop. You mind is full of Creationist's ideas instead. That's an example of 'full'
By the way I think he is tall, fat and big enough not to be in such situations. But your use of "fortunate" likely leads people to thinking that you expereinced such and such more terribly than they can imagine.
I believe they are the hardships you spent your time on from time to time.
 
brudally said:
well, that sounds familiar but your explanation doesn't show you have any knowledge about reasoning psychologically to how and what things are to go and stop. You mind is full of Creationist's ideas instead. That's an example of 'full'
By the way I think he is tall, fat and big enough not to be in such situations. But your use of "fortunate" likely leads people to thinking that you expereinced such and such more terribly than they can imagine.
I believe they are the hardships you spent your time on from time to time.
I'm sorry, I always try to be as generous as possible to non-native English speakers, but you are making absolutely no sense here.
 
Emieno said:
I agree that some cases of succide commitment come from depression but depression isn't a means that leads people to killing themselves.
If i knew what is *emptiness*, I would not ask you what is *full*. So could you tell me what it is?

Emptiness i hope is some thing you will never know, but try to imagine a cold
bleak day, and you think you are a failure in every thing that you do, you have
no motivation, life seems pointless, you think of various ways to end it all, but
you do not have the will power even to do that, you think no one likes you, even that they are plotting against you, you can think of nothing that will bring
happiness, your mind goes around in cycles thinking of all this.

Then some one shouts coffee up and all is better. :biggrin:
 
  • #10
Emieno said:
I agree that some cases of succide commitment come from depression but depression isn't a means that leads people to killing themselves.
If i knew what is *emptiness*, I would not ask you what is *full*. So could you tell me what it is?

In some cases the "emptiness" that you are describing is similar to being chronically lonely. Not lonely as in amount of people around (one can be lonely even in a huge group of people), but lonely in a way that one needs a very good friend to be around. But even then, the feeling may persist depending on the circumstances.

As MIH said, it is something that doesn't really go away. You wake up with it, and live out your day with it, doing nothing but merely "existing" without joy. It is a rather bleak existence at that, and many times those people just want to be loved and appreciated.
 
  • #11
The question;

"What does emptiness feel like"

Is self explanitory. "Empty" is the keyword here. There is no definition of something which doesn't exist. If you are feeling empty, you cannot feel depressed, nor happy. Emptiness = nothingness. You feel nothing, literally nothing. Try yourself to define "nothing" without coming back up with "nothing" (nothing is nothing), you can find many other words which mean nothing, but none which REALLY define nothing as something, its physically impossible.

So to answer your question, the feeling of emptiness is blank. You would not know if you were experienceing this feeling.

Emptiness has been used in books and films to describe many things such as a combination of many awful feelings e.g. distruaght abandoned, alone, bereft, blue, cheerless, comfortless, cynical, defenseless, depressed, deserted, despairing, desperate, despondent, destitute, destroyed, disconsolate, dragging, forgotten, forsaken, friendless, fruitless, futile, godforsaken, helpless, homeless, inconsolable, lonely, lonesome, lost, miserable, oppressed, pathetic, pessimistic, pitiable, pitiful, solitary, tragic, unhappy, weighed down.

But these are the actual correct feelings, together, they will never weight up to emptiness, because as I said, nothing cannot weight up to a something.

The feeling of literal emptiness is unknown to any living creature

I hope I make sense
 
  • #12
What is 'Emptiness'?
Like asking, "What is blue"?
Meditation was a very strong factor in my 'experience' of 'emptiness'. I began my search for 'Truth' by discarding that which is not Truth. From a very early age, I sensed a yawning emptiness where others found substance. I am not my role as husband; I am not my name; I am not my gender; I am not my body; I am not my car; etc.. ad nauseum! What did I find at the 'bottom' of that exceedingly deep rabbit hole? Nothing. Nothing at all. No family; no Me; no universe; no*thing* at all. Such emptiness! (you can't imagine that quality and quantity of 'emptiness'... (though, 'nothing' is perfect, it isn't very interesting!)

So, now, knowing the ultimate punchline of (my) 'life', that I have absolutely no substance (simply a hologramic 'thought' within Mind, a Dream, an 'egoic smudge'..) nor does anything else. No one 'else' exists but within Mind as a reflection of 'egoic Self'. I open my eyes and see you, the inside of my (mind) dream. I look in the mirror and see a Dreamer who is also a Dream, a fiction, to fade into the Wakefulness of eternal Emptiness...

Perhaps that vast 'Nothing', no thing, is Consciousness with nothing to be conscious of? Without the opium dream of 'existence'... Consciousness must be vastly, limitlessly, perfectly 'Empty'.
Our 'natural' state.
And the Dream only lasts a (Planck) moment...
 
Last edited:
  • #14
Emptiness.. hmm.. take that feeling you get when your first girlfriend you really love breaks up with you.. take that feeling you get when you just learned your parents died.. take that feel when you remember your best friend you loved with all your heart lying on her bed because she took an overdose of drugs.. and amplify it.

Nirvana I've experienced.. that's emptiness, souless, funny i don't know what it's like to be souless so I can't define it.

However, this human emotion factor is probably cause of some hormone or neurotransmitter.. or perhaps... some neural connections being stimulated or shut off. who knows?
 
Last edited:
  • #15
So it appears, so far, that 'emptiness' is available in a variety of 'flavors'...
 
  • #16
Emieno, You asked for a "definition" of the "concept" called emptiness. Where do we find definitions--in dictionaries. Now, what dictionary to use--great question--little agreement among philosophers. I use the Webster Unabridged Dictionary. Here we find the various definitions for the concept emptiness:
1. a state of being empty; a state containing nothing; absence of matter
2. void space; vacuity; vacuum
3. want of solidity or substance
4. want of intellect or knowledge; lack of sense
Now your thread asks, how can one "feel the emptiness". Then, what does it mean to "feel", e.g., how is this concept defined, as it may relate to emptiness. Again to Webster:
to feel--to be aware of the condition of being, as I feel sad.
Now, let us combine the two definitions (feel & emptiness) and we see that a "feeling of emptiness" can be defined as ---to be aware of the condition of having absence of matter. Many examples exist, consider if you have lost someone you love (absence of life), then you clearly understand what it means to be aware of absence of matter, you are aware of what it means to have a "feeling of emptiness". In short, you can never know the feeling of emptiness unless you are aware.
 
  • #17
how does mouse know cat is going to eat him
i had many cats , at times the alpha cat would catch a mouse but not kill ,
it was almost like the at diidnt kill mouse so homework would always have something to hunt and not be bored
 
  • #18
"Emptiness," analysis reduction, & the mouse "wants."

Hello everyone, the cat parasite Toxoplasma gondii in the sample http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/08/060804085444.htm" seems to be analogous with what a mouse "wants," under a particular condition however (ecology in general). Also, I recall something interesting on the life cycle of another parasite that spreads itself through birds predating on infected catapillars.

It was interesting to see the parasite influence on the infected catapillars, in a display that attracts the bird (does the catapillar "want" also?). Unfortunately, I do not know what the parasite was, and I observed the nature program long ago.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
Replies
27
Views
7K
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
8K