Register to reply

Black holes

by varsha
Tags: black, holes
Share this thread:
varsha
#1
Jan12-06, 06:22 AM
P: 56
i know that if a star having planets dies, and becomes a black hole the planets continue to revolve around the black hole. how is it possible when the black hole sucks everything??
Phys.Org News Partner Astronomy news on Phys.org
A new approach in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence: targeting alien polluters
Lives and deaths of sibling stars
Australian researchers pioneer a 'Google street view' of galaxies
Garth
#2
Jan12-06, 07:05 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
Garth's Avatar
P: 3,273
Hi varsha and welcome to these Forums!
Quote Quote by varsha
i know that if a star having planets dies, and becomes a black hole the planets continue to revolve around the black hole. how is it possible when the black hole sucks everything??
So did the star (sucks everything) before it became a BH, its called gravity, that is why the planets have to orbit around it.

Garth
DaveC426913
#3
Jan12-06, 08:53 AM
DaveC426913's Avatar
P: 15,319
Quote Quote by varsha
how is it possible when the black hole sucks everything??
Simply put, a black hole sucks in no more than anything else does.

A black hole's gravity is entirely dependent on its mass, same as an ordinary star, including this BH-formerly-know-as-a-star. Presuming that, when the star collapsed, it did not lose any mass, then its gravity has not changed. The planets, gravity-wise, see no change. Neither would a spaceship in orbit.


What is surely confusing you is this: the newly formed black hole can and does have hugely strong gravity (as you've read) - but only in the space where the star used to be.

I refer you to the attached diagram for clarification.

Planet's gravity well on the right, BH on the left. Note that, since both objects are the same mass, they both have the same curvature (gravitational pull).

Now, note how much pull the spaceship s1 experiences in the left diagram and in the right diagram - it's the same in both. Note how much pull spaceship s2 experiences: same.

But look at spaceship s3 - it only exists in the BH diagram because in the star diagram it would be below the surface of the star. It can get very close to the BH, since it's much smaller, and there, it can experience an extremely strong gravitational pull.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Black holes and white holes Cosmology 5
Re: White Holes are time-reversed black holes? General Physics 0
Are black holes black afterall? Astronomy & Astrophysics 22
White holes, black holes Astronomy & Astrophysics 6