Ventilation Systems: Calculating G & E Rates

In summary, the conversation discusses the difference between rate of generation and rate of evaporation in the context of a chemical system. The question is whether the loss of 1 gallon per day should be considered as rate of generation (G) or rate of evaporation (E). The concept of generation is not fully understood, and it is compared to the more self-explanatory concept of evaporation. One possible interpretation is that generation refers to the amount of substance that enters the system, while evaporation is the amount lost. A formula is provided to illustrate the relationship between the change in volume of water and the amount gained and lost through the day. Overall, there is still some ambiguity about the meaning of generation in this context.
  • #1
melpec
1
0
Hi...Prbably a stupid question but here it goes:

I have some equations here, some of them have a G for rate of generation and others have E for rate of evaporation (both of them have units of volume per time).

My question is: if I know that I have 3 galons of a chemical at the beggining of the day in one tank and at the end of the day I only have 2 galon...then I lost 1 galon per day...but is this number E or G? I mean...I don't understand what is the difference, I know there is an equation relating them but I don't understand the concept.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Is the problem that you don't understand the difference between Generation and Evaporation?

What is meant by generation in this context?

Evaporation is pretty self explanatory with regards to the description, however generation remains ambiguous with what you have described.

Generation sounds like it could possibly describe, among other things, the water condensation in a system.?

You have a variable volume, if you know the rate of evaporation and your final volume you can therefor calculate how much of the substance has entered the system ( possibly what generation is referring to here ).


Consider a sink of water. Water evaporates throughout the day, and you start with a known volume(V). At the end of the day you measure again the volume of water in the sink(V`).

From a formula for the rate evaporation (based on the conditions) you know that you loose x amount of water through evaporation during the day.

You know that the change in the volume of water is related to the amount of water lost and the amount of water gained through the day, where G is the amount gained.

(V`-V) = G - x

That is one possible interpretation of the meaning of Generation and G in this context. I am guessing though.
 
  • #3


Hi there,

Your question is not a stupid one at all! It's actually a great question and shows that you are thinking critically about the equations and their meanings.

To answer your question, the difference between G and E rates is the source of the change in volume. G stands for generation, which means it is the rate at which the substance is being produced or generated. E stands for evaporation, which means it is the rate at which the substance is being lost due to evaporation.

In your example, if you started with 3 gallons of the chemical and ended with 2 gallons, then the difference is 1 gallon. This would be considered a G rate, because the change in volume was due to the generation of the substance.

However, if the change in volume was due to evaporation, then it would be considered an E rate. Let's say you started with 3 gallons and ended with 0 gallons. The difference of 3 gallons would be an E rate, because the change in volume was due to evaporation.

I hope this helps to clarify the concept for you. Keep asking questions and thinking critically about the equations, it will help you understand them better. Good luck!
 

What is the purpose of a ventilation system?

A ventilation system is designed to provide fresh air and remove stale air from an enclosed space. This helps to maintain a healthy and comfortable indoor environment by regulating the levels of oxygen, moisture, and pollutants.

What is the difference between G and E rates in ventilation systems?

G and E rates refer to the amount of air that is brought into a space (G) and the amount of air that is exhausted from the space (E). G and E rates are important factors in determining the effectiveness of a ventilation system and ensuring proper air circulation.

How are G and E rates calculated?

G and E rates are typically calculated using the ventilation rate procedure, which takes into account the size and type of space, occupancy levels, and the desired air exchange rate. The formula used to calculate G and E rates varies depending on the specific ventilation standards being followed.

What are the recommended G and E rates for different types of spaces?

The recommended G and E rates vary depending on the type of space and its intended use. For example, residential buildings typically have a recommended G rate of 0.35 air changes per hour and an E rate of 0.25 air changes per hour. In contrast, commercial buildings may have a higher recommended G rate of 1.5 air changes per hour and an E rate of 1.0 air changes per hour.

What factors can affect the G and E rates in a ventilation system?

There are several factors that can affect the G and E rates in a ventilation system, including the design of the system, the condition of the building, and the outdoor climate. Other factors such as occupant behavior, air leaks, and equipment malfunctions can also impact the G and E rates and should be regularly monitored and adjusted as necessary.

Similar threads

  • General Engineering
2
Replies
51
Views
5K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
15
Views
650
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • General Engineering
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
48
Views
9K
  • General Engineering
Replies
4
Views
11K
  • General Engineering
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
15
Views
534
Back
Top