- #1
Jupiter60
- 79
- 22
Does a spiritual, mental, emotional and abstract plane of existence exist in addition to the physical plane of existence, or is everything physical?
Last edited:
dipole said:Your question really isn't meaningful, because you haven't defined what you mean by 'physical'.
If, by physical, you're referring to the existence of an objective reality - then the answer to your question is probably no. Quantum mechanics seems to suggest that there is no objective reality, and that there do indeed exist things, but which can't be measured.
For example, when a system is some quantum superposition, both of the possibilities are equally "real", but when you go to measure the system, only one outcome is possible - however that doesn't mean the other outcome didn't exist...
Additionally, there's the whole EPR paradox, and Einstein's major objection to quantum mechanics was this implication of no objective reality.
Now, if by physical you mean "something which can be measured", then I would still say the answer is no. Look at mathematical truths, which have yet to be proven or discovered. The fact that [itex] a^2 + b^2 = c^2 [/itex] for a right triangle was always true (in Euclidean space), long before human beings even existed - so in some sense, that truth must have "existed", we just weren't aware of it.
Yes and questions of uniqueness are kind irrelevant also.:tongue2:johnqwertyful said:Any questions of existence IMO are meaningless.
"Spiritual", mental, and emotional experiences all take place on the physical plane. All three are neurological/physiological experiences. A "spiritual" experience might be anything from an unexplained sense of well being to a full blown hallucination of heaven or hell, but that experience is being generated by the activity of real, physical neurons, as are mental and emotional experiences. No neurons, no experience. (Well, I shouldn't speak for jellyfish, so, more broadly, no physical existence, no experiences.)Jupiter60 said:Does a spiritual, mental, emotional and abstract plane of existence exist in addition to the physical plane of existence, or is everything physical?
Now, if by physical you mean "something which can be measured", then I would still say the answer is no. Look at mathematical truths, which have yet to be proven or discovered. The fact that a2+b2=c2 for a right triangle was always true (in Euclidean space), long before human beings even existed - so in some sense, that truth must have "existed", we just weren't aware of it.
Jupiter60 said:Does a spiritual, mental, emotional and abstract plane of existence exist in addition to the physical plane of existence, or is everything physical?
In this context, "spiritual life" refers to a non-physical existence or consciousness that is separate from the physical world and the laws of physics.
Currently, there is no scientific evidence that definitively proves the existence of a spiritual life beyond physical reality. However, there are ongoing studies and research exploring the potential for consciousness to exist outside of the physical body.
It is possible that spiritual life and the laws of physics can coexist, but this is a topic that is still widely debated and explored in both scientific and philosophical communities.
Near-death experiences, while often described as spiritual or transcendent, are not considered scientific evidence for the existence of a spiritual life beyond physical reality. These experiences can be influenced by various factors, such as brain chemistry and personal beliefs.
This is an ongoing and complex topic of discussion in the scientific community. Some scientists and philosophers believe that the existence of a spiritual life beyond physical reality is incompatible with current scientific understanding, while others argue that it is possible to integrate the two perspectives.