Are Vectors Defined by Commutation Relations Always Roots in Any Representation?

[spookyfish]

The vectors $\vec{\alpha}=\{\alpha_1,\ldots\alpha_m \}$ are defined by
$$[H_i,E_\alpha]=\alpha_i E_\alpha$$
they are also known to be the non-zero weights, called the roots, in the adjoint representation. My question is - is this connection (that the vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ defined by the commutation relations above in some representation, are also the roots of the adjoint representation) is true only when $\vec{\alpha}$ is in the defining representation, or is it true for any representation?
I hope my question is clear

 

[andrien]

Which other representation of roots? Are you talking about the basis of the roots like Cartan-weyl basis or Dynkin basis?

 

[spookyfish]

No. Sorry, I am talking about the representation in which $\vec{\alpha}$ is defined. for example, in su(3), the defining representation has 3 weights (because the space is 3 dimensional) and the vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ are the difference between these weights. The vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ also coincide with the roots of the adjoint representation.
Now, suppose I wanted to consider a different arbitrary representation of su(3), not the 3-dimensional and not the adjoint 8-dimensional. It would have a different number of weights. Would the root vectors (same roots vectors, defined in the adjoint representation) still carry me between the different weights, or will they now not coincide with the vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ satisfying
$$[H_i,E_\alpha]=\alpha_i E_\alpha$$

 

[Bill_K]

The root vectors are not defined in the adjoint representation, or any representation, they are defined in the Lie Algebra, by the formula you gave,
$$[H_i, E_\alpha]=\alpha_i E_\alpha$$

Would the root vectors (same roots vectors, defined in the adjoint representation) still carry me between the different weights

Yes, this is easy to show. If m is an eikenket of H with weight m, namely H|m> = m |m>, then E_α|m> is an eigenket with weight m + α. This follows from the above commutator.

 

[spookyfish]

I see. But since $H_i$ and $E_\vec{\alpha}$ are different in different representations, aren't the root vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ also different?

then, if they are, either they are equal to the weights in the adjoint representation, or not.

 

[Bill_K]

I see. But since $H_i$ and $E_\vec{\alpha}$ are different in different representations, aren't the root vectors $\vec{\alpha}$ also different?

H and E_α are elements of the Lie algebra. In any representation there will be matrices that correspond to them, but the commutators of those matrices (and hence the root vectors) had better be the same, or else it would not be a representation!

Note that the root vectors are always ℓ-dimensional vectors, where ℓ is the rank of the group. They don't depend on the dimensionality of the representation.

 

[spookyfish]

I see. Thank you