Register to reply

Don't understand what is exchanging with what in this acid/base equili

by alex_alex
Tags: acid base, equilibrium
Share this thread:
alex_alex
#1
Apr8-14, 01:42 PM
P: 2
NH4+ + H2O (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H3O+;

the same reaction can be written as:
NH4+ + HO- (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H2O;

where (kf) - rate of forward reaction and (kr) - rate of reverse reaction.

1 Question. NH4+ or NH3 exchanging with H2O?

If NH4+ is exchanging with H2O:
NH4+ (k-1) =(k1) H2O,

where (k1) - rate of exchange from NH4+ to H2O and (k-1) - rate of exchange from H2O to NH4+.


If NH3is exchanging with H2O:
NH3(k-1) =(k1) H2O,

where (k1) - rate of exchange from NH3 to H2O and (k-1) - rate of exchange from H2O to NH3.

2 Question. What is the relationship between k1, k-1 and kf, kr?
Phys.Org News Partner Chemistry news on Phys.org
Faster, cheaper tests for sickle cell disease
Simulations for better transparent oxide layers
Characterizing strontium ruthenate crystals for electrochemical applications
Borek
#2
Apr8-14, 02:28 PM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 23,599
Quote Quote by alex_alex View Post
NH4+ + H2O (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H3O+;

the same reaction can be written as:
NH4+ + HO- (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H2O;
I don't see why you assume it is the same reaction with the same rate constants. They are definitely related to the same equilibrium, but that's all.
alex_alex
#3
Apr8-14, 02:35 PM
P: 2
Quote Quote by Borek View Post
I don't see why you assume it is the same reaction with the same rate constants. They are definitely related to the same equilibrium, but that's all.
At pH=7, I assume that 1st one is the most likely case. I am not sure I understand NH4+ or NH3 is exchanging H+ with H2O?

Borek
#4
Apr8-14, 02:47 PM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 23,599
Don't understand what is exchanging with what in this acid/base equili

To be honest, I have no idea what the exact mechanism is - at the same time I don't think it matters. Equilibrium doesn't depend on these details, and it is equilibrium that we are typically interested in.

Please note there is no such thing as H+ nor OH- in the solution. H3O+ is only an approximation, as proton is most likely solvated by more than one water molecule. OH- is solvated as well, so it is present as - at least - H3O2-. We ignore all these and it doesn't interfere with our understanding of acid/base reactions, why should it matter for ammonia?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
The weak acid conjugate base - something i can't understand. Chemistry 4
Find the molecular mass of acid in acid base neutralization Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 6
Acid-Base Titrations - Soda Lime and Hydrochloric Acid Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 7
Weak acid/strong base titration (Acetic acid/NaOH) Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 4
Titrating weak acid buffer with strong acid after the base is used up Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 6