Register to reply 
Can a phasor have a negative magnitude? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Mar2114, 12:21 PM

P: 45

Would it be preferred to write ##60\angle 10°\quad or\quad 60\angle 190°?##
Would one or the other be incorrect? Those two phasors are equivalent, right? 


#3
Mar2114, 06:07 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,161

The 'magnitude' in each case is 60. Magnitude is always positive. The angle of the phasor can be described using a sign. So your post is correct but the answer to the title is no.



#4
Mar2114, 10:51 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 1,910

Can a phasor have a negative magnitude?
Given the rectangular x and y components of a phasor, the direction is the Arctangent(y/x),
while magnitude = Sqrt(x*x + y*y). The square root of the sum of squares will never be negative. 


#5
Mar2214, 11:36 AM

P: 788

IIRC you need the fourquadrant version atan2(y, x) to get the phase.



#6
Mar2214, 04:06 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 3,661

As Sophie indicated  you should form the habit of magnitude positive, angle where it falls.
That's just "how it's done". to use a parallel from the dictionary  Words like "irregardless" and "drownded" are in the dictionary but carry stylistic label "substandard", meaning not used by people considered educated. Pronunciation of the word "nuclear" as "nookyuler" used to be labelled "substandard". But after three US presidents used it, it was upgraded to "nonstandard" meaning "not correct but used by many people who are considered educated". The inference is they should know better. Ever read that section in the front of Webster's, "Stylistic Labels" ? It's kinda fun. Nookyuler might even be just an alternate pronunciation nowadays  it was 1970's last time i looked.. So use negative magnitude as an aid in your thinking until you no longer need it, just don't admit to it. old jim 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Finding voltage phasor resistance * current phasor  Introductory Physics Homework  2  
Find phasor voltages, current, phasor diagrams  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  13  
Can the magnitude of vector be negative?  General Physics  4  
Why a phasor consists of the magnitude of a voltage multiplied  Electrical Engineering  4  
Why does a bight object like the sun have negative magnitude?  Astronomy & Astrophysics  4 