Getting comfortable with homological algebra

  • Thread starter Tiger99
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Algebra
In summary, it seems that it will take a lot of work to become comfortable with cohomology theory, but it's worth it in the end.
  • #1
Tiger99
41
0
Hello, I've been trying to learn about cohomology theory (particularly in relation to Lie algebras, the Hochschild cohomology and deformations of algebras) and I never seem to get very far.

It seems there's a bit of a jump between knowing what Ext and Tor mean and actually feeling comfortable with them and feeling confident that I can actually calculate them, and knowing when you can calculate them. Maybe I'm just being lazy. I have to keep looking up the definitions of each every time I see them being used in something (I'm thinking of making myself a little card to put in my wallet). Does anyone have some tips? Are there some exercises that you worked through to get the hang of it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Are you using Weibel's book? It has a lot of good exercises, and the text itself is really nice. It even has a chapter on Lie algebra cohomology and another on Hochschild stuff.

In any case, it's pretty common to feel overwhelmed when you start dabbling in homological algebra. I think one of the main reasons for this is that the question "What the hell is this crap good for?" doesn't have a convincing answer for the beginner. The only way to get a convincing answer is, in my experience, by simply keeping at it and learning a lot of concrete math which uses homological algebra constantly--two obvious candidates here are topology (both differential and algebraic) and algebraic geometry.

For example, Ext and Tor show up in topology as obstructions to what would be the naive change of base-group operation in cohomology and homology. Look up the "universal coefficient theorem" in any algebraic topology book (IIRC Hatcher had a good exposition of this) to see what I mean. I found this helped me really appreciate the "obstruction"ness of Ext and Tor, although the usual spiel about extension of modules and free resolutions is actually pretty illuminating.

I also recommend the article by Burt Totaro on Algebraic Topology in the Princeton Companion to Mathematics. It's really well-written and I think it gives the reader a good general idea of why homology and cohomology are useful.

In the same vein I recommend the book by Dieudonné called something like "A History of Differential and Algebraic Topology". I wouldn't read this with the goal of understanding what each sentence means, but rather I'd use the book to help me draw a mental image of how homological algebra came to be.

Also, for Lie algebra cohomology, have you checked out the Chevalley-Eilenberg paper? It might be instructive to go over it and compare with Weibel.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Thanks Morphism for all your advice.

Yes, I've been looking at Weibel's book. I went away for the summer and couldn't take it with me, but now I'm back home so I will try to read it again, and look at the book by Cartan and Eilenberg too, and the Chevalley and Eilenberg paper.

I suppose I was just being lazy. There are many little things that trip me up and probably shouldn't. For example, I had trouble getting comfortable with projective resolutions, because I don't think I would recognise a non-projective module when I see one. At first, actually I couldn't think of modules that weren't projective (by looking at the diagram definition).

Now with the help of the internet, I know that Q is not projective as a Z-module (and I understand that one), and abelian groups are projective as Z-modules only if they're free.

It seems like I need to know a bit more of everything.

Thanks again.
 

1. What is homological algebra?

Homological algebra is a branch of mathematics that studies algebraic structures using tools from topology, abstract algebra, and category theory. It is concerned with the study of complexes, chain complexes, and homology groups, and their relationships to algebraic structures such as rings, modules, and groups.

2. Why is homological algebra important?

Homological algebra has applications in many areas of mathematics and science, including algebraic geometry, topology, and physics. It provides powerful tools for understanding and classifying algebraic structures, and has connections to other branches of mathematics such as representation theory and number theory.

3. What are some key concepts in homological algebra?

Some key concepts in homological algebra include exact sequences, homology and cohomology, derived functors, and spectral sequences. These concepts are used to study the properties and relationships of algebraic structures, and have many applications in mathematics and science.

4. How can I become comfortable with homological algebra?

Becoming comfortable with homological algebra takes time and practice. It is important to have a strong foundation in abstract algebra, topology, and category theory. Reading textbooks and working through exercises can also help solidify understanding. Additionally, attending seminars and workshops on the topic can provide opportunities for further learning and discussion.

5. What are some common challenges in learning homological algebra?

Homological algebra can be a challenging subject due to its use of abstract concepts and techniques. Some common challenges include understanding the relationships between different algebraic structures, working with complex diagrams and computations, and understanding the connections to other branches of mathematics. It is important to be patient and persistent in learning this subject, and to seek help and clarification when needed.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
15
Views
323
  • Linear and Abstract Algebra
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Topology and Analysis
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
33
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
5
Views
785
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
8
Views
2K
Back
Top