Is it possible to build a catch all electormagnetic wave spectrum generator?

In summary, the conversation discusses the proposal of a device that can capture all forms of electromagnetic radiation using charged particles and a conductive solution. An alternative option is an electromagnetic fabric made of variable-sized antennas. However, the professor points out that it would not generate much energy due to the conservation of energy. The idea of converting salt beds or deserts into electromagnetic catching generators is brought up, but it is noted that this would not be feasible due to the second law of thermodynamics.
  • #1
GreenAce92
41
0
I had "posited" or proposed this idea to a professor of mine about building a device which could capture all forms of electromagnetic radiation with varying sized charged particles and a solution that was conductive.

Another option is a type of electromagnetic fabric which is basically variable sized antennas from nm to meter scale, sort of like expanding exponential curves that are made from conductive wire that capture stray electromagnetic waves.

For the example in the first paragraph (sentence) I thought it could capture everything from xrays, infrared, light etc...

My professor said it wouldn't generate much energy.

What if it was really big! Let's say we converted the salt beds / deserts into these electromagnetic catching generators?

Is it worth investigating?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
It would not generate any energy, as energy is conserved. You descibe an object known as perfect black body. There are very good approximations to this, but they cannot be used to harvest energy (unless you expose them to sunlight, solarthermal power plants exist) - in thermal equilibrium, they have to radiate away the same amount of energy, this follows from the second law of thermodynamics.
 

1. Can a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator be built?

As a scientist, I cannot definitively say whether it is possible or not to build a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator. However, based on current technology and scientific understanding, it is highly unlikely. The electromagnetic spectrum is extremely vast and complex, and creating a device that can generate all of its waves would require an immense amount of power and precision.

2. What is the purpose of a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator?

A catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator would theoretically allow for the manipulation and control of all types of electromagnetic waves, including radio waves, microwaves, infrared, visible light, ultraviolet, x-rays, and gamma rays. This could have various applications in communication, medical imaging, and other fields, but the technology to achieve this is currently not available.

3. Has anyone successfully built a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator?

No, to date, there has not been a successful attempt at building a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator. While there have been advancements in technology that allow for the manipulation of certain types of electromagnetic waves, the ability to generate and control the entire spectrum remains elusive.

4. What are the challenges in building a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator?

One of the main challenges in building a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator is the vast range of frequencies and wavelengths that need to be generated and controlled. This requires advanced technology and precise engineering, which is difficult to achieve on such a large scale. Additionally, the potential safety risks and ethical considerations surrounding the use of such a device must also be taken into account.

5. Is there ongoing research or development in this area?

Yes, there is ongoing research and development in the field of electromagnetic wave generation and manipulation. Scientists and engineers are constantly exploring new technologies and methods to improve our understanding and control of the electromagnetic spectrum. However, the concept of a catch all electromagnetic wave spectrum generator remains a theoretical possibility and is not currently being pursued as a practical goal.

Similar threads

Ball Lightning Debunk, New Proposal
    • General Discussion
Replies
2
Views
3K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top