What Makes a Ballon Move?

  • Thread starter nolachrymose
  • Start date
In summary: Goddard's demonstration of using expelled gases as a means of propulsion was the first to be successfully performed.
  • #1
nolachrymose
71
0
Hi all,

I'm relatively new to physics, and was curious: when one does let the air release out of a ballon, why does it, and in which way is its force acting? I thought maybe the direction of the force was in the opposite direction it was traveling, but that doesn't seem to make much sense, since that would mean it wouldn't move because of Newton's third law. And does the amount of air surrounding the balloon have any effect on its force (i.e. would it move differently in a vacuum?)? Any information would be greatly appreciated! Thanks! :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
basically what's happening is the air pressure in the balloon is what pushes the air out of the balloon. and since every action has a reaction the air then pushes the balloon. it would move the same in a vacuum. this is kind of how spaceships move in space.
 
  • #3
bino said:
basically what's happening is the air pressure in the balloon is what pushes the air out of the balloon. and since every action has a reaction the air then pushes the balloon. it would move the same in a vacuum. this is kind of how spaceships move in space.

This is exactly how spaceships move in space. They accelerate a gas of somekind, rocket exhaust, steam, compressed air, etc. out a nozzle and the reaction force acclerates the spaceship. Newton's Third Law at work!
 
  • #4
Rocket motion not only involves the third law, but also the law of conservation of momentum. As the rocket loses mass in the form of exhausts it gains velocity.
 
  • #5
If it were in a vacuum, I believe the balloon would fly in a parabola (or a straight line if there is no gravity). I think the funky flightpath we see is due to aerodynamical effects caused by fluctuations in balloon shape as it shrinks.

Balloon rubber elasticity causes pressure. This pressure pushes [air] in one direction and [air + ballon] in the other direction. Because of symetry (cylindrical symetry), all other forces in all other directions cancel out. Only one pair of forces remain, and Newton's 3rd law takes care of it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
Thank you for the information.
However, I have one more question: if the only two forces (as you said all others cancel out) are the equal and opposite forces, then how is it that the balloon moves, rather than remaining stationary?
 
  • #7
nolachrymose said:
Thank you for the information.
However, I have one more question: if the only two forces (as you said all others cancel out) are the equal and opposite forces, then how is it that the balloon moves, rather than remaining stationary?

The forces are equal and opposite - they don't "cancel." The expelled air moves one way and the balloon moves the other way.
 
  • #8
nolachrymose said:
Thank you for the information.
However, I have one more question: if the only two forces (as you said all others cancel out) are the equal and opposite forces, then how is it that the balloon moves, rather than remaining stationary?

I said that the pressure pushes [(more) air] in one direction and [(less) air + (all the rubber from the) balloon] in the other. This is because there is a hole only on one end. For it to remain stationnary, you would need another hole, opposite to the first.
 
  • #9
Tide said:
The forces are equal and opposite - they don't "cancel." The expelled air moves one way and the balloon moves the other way.

It is the forces acting laterally to balloon trajectory that cancel out. Not the pair of opposites that causes the trajectory.
 
  • #10
FYI- The idea that a spacecraft could use expelled gases as thrust was first proven by an american rocket scientist by the name of Robert Goddard. He is known as the american father of rocketry and is ranked up there with Oberth and Tsiolkovsky. One of his first, and simplest experiements that proved this theory was conducted by placed a pistol inside a vacuum and then shooting blank rounds. The gun, which was connected to a pipe which was free to rotate, spun in circles. This was the first time the theory had been proven correct.
Most of you probably already knew this... but i thought it was an interesting part to the story.
 
  • #11
Well, actually Tsoliovsky figured it out first, but Goddard didn't have access to the research, so it was credited to him as well.

Welcome to PF anti-flag! :smile:
 
  • #12
First of all thank you enigma for the welcome.
Secondly... i guess that's what i get for believing things i read out of biographies. Was goddard at least the first to experimentally prove it??
Thanks again
 
  • #13
Yes, Goddard was.

From http://www.spaceline.org/history/21.html on Tsiolkovsky (you had the spelling right... I can never remember it):

Tsiolkovsky completed a draft of his first design of a reaction thrust motor on August 25, 1898.

Although practical strides in rocketry were being made at this time in other parts of the world, Tsiolkovsky never saw his designs materialize. His rocket motors were neither built nor tested, primarily due to Russian political instability, lack of resources and inadequate technical personnel.

Goddard was 16 at that time according to http://www.time.com/time/time100/scientist/profile/goddard.html and his first rocket test was on March 16th, 1926.
 

1. How does a balloon move?

A balloon moves because of the air or gas inside of it. When the balloon is filled with air or gas, the molecules inside push against the walls of the balloon, causing it to expand and become round. This expansion creates pressure, and as the air or gas tries to escape, it pushes against the walls of the balloon, causing it to move in the opposite direction.

2. What type of gas makes a balloon move?

The type of gas that makes a balloon move is helium. Helium is a lighter-than-air gas, meaning it is less dense than the surrounding air. When helium is filled inside a balloon, it makes the balloon less dense than the surrounding air, causing it to rise and move upwards.

3. Why do balloons deflate and stop moving?

Balloons deflate and stop moving because the air or gas inside them escapes. Over time, the molecules of the gas become smaller and spread out, causing the pressure inside the balloon to decrease. As a result, the balloon becomes less buoyant and eventually deflates.

4. How does the size of a balloon affect its movement?

The size of a balloon affects its movement because it determines the amount of air or gas that can be held inside. A larger balloon can hold more air or gas, making it more buoyant and able to move more easily. However, if a balloon becomes too large, the weight of the rubber may overcome the buoyancy of the gas and cause it to sink.

5. Can a balloon move in a vacuum?

No, a balloon cannot move in a vacuum because there is no air or gas present to create pressure and push against the walls of the balloon. Without any air or gas inside, the balloon would simply float in the vacuum without any movement.

Similar threads

Replies
76
Views
7K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
865
Replies
35
Views
3K
  • Mechanics
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
52
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Back
Top