Filling up gas tank with same $ amount

  • Thread starter srfriggen
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Gas Tank
In summary: I imagine you would run out of gas sooner than if you just bought $10 worth on each of those days.In summary, my econ professor taught that if you put $10 into your tank no matter what the gas price is, over time you will save more money than if you always filled the tank to a certain level.
  • #1
srfriggen
306
5
My econ teacher told us that his father would always put in $10 of gas in his car no matter what the price of gas was.

He showed that mathematically his father would come out on top. I know that there are a lot of ways people discuss about how much you should fill your tank (some say fill it up all the way you'll save, etc) but that has more to do with how the car works. The fixed rate of spending I believe was more tied into the fluctuation of gas prices.

Does anyone know the formula/way to describe what my econ professor taught us? It's been too long and I forgot it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
regardless, the theory is that were I to put in $10 into my tank through any time period, over time I would save more money than if I always filled the tank to a certain level, i.e. always topping it off, or always filling it halfway, etc.

Anyone know how to prove that?
 
  • #4
I don't know why this would be true, much less significant. A couple of effects I can think of:

1. Not filling your tank all the way means you are storing less gas, which means you are loaning the gas company less money and therefore earning interest on the money that stays in your bank account. So, for example, if it averages $20 to fill your tank, you're holding $10 more in your bank account and earning interest on it.

2. Gas prices tend to rise with time, with or without an inflation adjustment. So buying later means buying at a higher price; filling your tank means investing in gas futures.

3. I'm not sure if the constant $$ is significant to your prof's logic, but over time, your $10 will mean buying less gas, so the amount you are storing for the gas company is dropping. So if your $10 started off buying you a full tank and now only buys you a half tank, you have "saved" $10 a few pennies at a time by buying less gas each time. Of course, this is not permanent in and of itself. Then again, I made it permanent recently by trading-in a car with an empty tank of gas while buying my new car with a full tank. So essentially the car dealer unintentionally gave me $60 worth of gas.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
There is a similar investment strategy called dollar cost averaging. The idea is you buy a fixed dollar amount of stock every month, say $100. Then, you buy more shares when the stock is down, and fewer shares when the stock is up, which reduces your average cost per share of buying the stock. Whether it is an effective strategy or not is debatable, but some people swear by it..

Edit: I just ran some numerical simulations that show that this does work. Assume the price of gas has no long term trend, but fluctuates randomly with a normal distribution. If the average price of gas is $4.00 with a sigma of $0.50, you will pay an average price of $3.93 with this strategy. If the sigma is $1.00, you will pay an average price of $3.68.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
phyzguy said:
There is a similar investment strategy called dollar cost averaging. The idea is you buy a fixed dollar amount of stock every month, say $100. Then, you buy more shares when the stock is down, and fewer shares when the stock is up, which reduces your average cost per share of buying the stock. Whether it is an effective strategy or not is debatable, but some people swear by it..

Edit: I just ran some numerical simulations that show that this does work. Assume the price of gas has no long term trend, but fluctuates randomly with a normal distribution. If the average price of gas is $4.00 with a sigma of $0.50, you will pay an average price of $3.93 with this strategy. If the sigma is $1.00, you will pay an average price of $3.68.

Dollar cost averaging is a losing strategy assuming stocks have a higher expected return than cash, the market is just as likely to crash after the last dollar is averaged in than it is after a lump sum investment, leaving the difference the opportunity cost of holding cash during the DCA period.

Your simulation does not say much because the mean is known. Basically in it you "know" the avg price of a gallon of gas is 4 so naturally one would buy as little as possible when the price is over $4.
 
  • #8
Does he factor in the fact that he actually drives the car?

$10 on Monday and $10 on Friday is basically the same as $20 on Monday.

I don't see how this works when considering recurring costs...
 
  • #9
phyzguy said:
There is a similar investment strategy called dollar cost averaging. The idea is you buy a fixed dollar amount of stock every month, say $100. Then, you buy more shares when the stock is down, and fewer shares when the stock is up, which reduces your average cost per share of buying the stock. Whether it is an effective strategy or not is debatable, but some people swear by it..

Edit: I just ran some numerical simulations that show that this does work. Assume the price of gas has no long term trend, but fluctuates randomly with a normal distribution. If the average price of gas is $4.00 with a sigma of $0.50, you will pay an average price of $3.93 with this strategy. If the sigma is $1.00, you will pay an average price of $3.68.

I'm almost positive this is what my econ prof was speaking of. I was thinking about it last night and realized why this would be a viable strategy... you beat me to it!
Whether this is up for debate or not wasn't my original question. Was just trying to remember the theory. But thank you all for the input.

Note: I'm a math major now, so the realities of how a car works or whether or not one even drives the car don't matter to me! ;)
 
  • #10
Like most economic problems, it becomes a tautology based on debatable assumptions. If you assume the price of gas will appreciate with inflation and an individual cannot earn an after-tax risk free rate of return on savings >= the rate of inflation (certainly true today) then the optimal strategy is to keep the tank full
 
Last edited:
  • #11
srfriggen said:
I'm a math major now, so the realities of how a car works or whether or not one even drives the car don't matter to me! ;)

As an engineer, this hurts my head haha
 
  • #12
Travis_King said:
$10 on Monday and $10 on Friday is basically the same as $20 on Monday.
It's not quite the same, because you might not have $20 on Monday (suppose you get paid on Thursdays for example), and even if you do have the $20 on Monday, only spending $10 on gas means you have the option of spending the other $10 on something else. For example if you car breaks down you could spend the $10 on a taxi, but you can't give the taxi driver $10 worth of gas from your broken down car. An economist would say "money is fungible, but gasoline is not".

I don't see how this works when considering recurring costs...

I guess this was supposed to be an example of dollar cost averaging, but it's a poor example IMO. The biggest flaw is that if you drive a constant mileage per day and the price of gas rises, you have to spend $10 more often than you did before, or you will soon run out of gas.
 
  • #13
AlephZero said:
The biggest flaw is that if you drive a constant mileage per day and the price of gas rises, you have to spend $10 more often than you did before, or you will soon run out of gas.

This was my first thought, $10 doesn't buy a whole lot of gas these days...
 

1. How many gallons of gas will I get for a certain dollar amount?

The number of gallons you will get for a certain dollar amount depends on the current price of gas. Divide the dollar amount by the price per gallon to determine the number of gallons you will get.

2. Why does the amount of gas I get for the same dollar amount vary?

The price of gas is constantly changing due to factors such as supply and demand, location, and taxes. This can affect the amount of gas you get for the same dollar amount.

3. Can I get the same amount of gas for a lower price by shopping around?

Yes, you may be able to find a lower price per gallon by shopping around at different gas stations. However, keep in mind that the distance you travel may offset any savings you may get from a lower price.

4. Is it better to fill up my gas tank when it's half empty or completely empty?

It is generally recommended to fill up your gas tank when it is half empty. This can help prevent running out of gas and also allows for more flexibility in choosing where to fill up.

5. How often should I fill up my gas tank with the same dollar amount?

This depends on your individual driving habits and the size of your gas tank. It is important to keep track of your gas mileage and refill your tank before it gets too low to avoid running out of gas.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • General Engineering
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
735
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
22
Views
5K
Replies
92
Views
8K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
20
Views
1K
Back
Top