What is the true definition of 'observe' in quantum physics?

  • Thread starter Tapiolas
  • Start date
In summary: There is a simpler and more straightforward explanation for what is going on, and it does not involve consciousness or any sort of human agency.
  • #1
Tapiolas
1
0
I would appreciate if someone could clarify or give me a definition of 'observe' in respect to quantum physics.

I originally thought that when a particle is not being 'observed' it is not in contact with other particles of photons etc. but a recent book seemed to imply that 'observe' means to enter consciousness.

Clarification of this point would be helpful.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Clarify

hi
The question you ask must be clarified first .
Is your question about Observation Definition? or About Observation machanism ?

If you mean the definition i think your question have the answer included .
But if you aim to the mechanism . We must ask about the sensing mechanism of the observer 1st .
 
  • #3
Consciousness is irrelevent

Observation has absolutely nothing to do with consciousness or human agency or even with measurement (which implies human agency). Even the linguistic term 'observation' is outmoded, privileged, semantically overloaded, and no longer used by people versed in quantum theory.

The way I understand it, in order for a particle to get realized, it does not have to be observed. All it has to do is pass information (on the variable of interest) to the environment. This is as simple as an atom emitting a photon (which is entangled and hence cohered with the atom). Once this photon strikes the environment, such as a molecule that happens to be in its path, and the ***information is transferred*** decoherence happens, the wavefunction will collapse, and the particle is realized. Please see Zurek, lanl.gov, "Decoherence and the Transition from Quantum to Classical - Revisited". See in particular last half of page 21.

Those who are pushing a consciousness explanation are religionists and mystics whose god has been historically kicked out of its top perch, and now they are attempting to find him in lowly photons as a last resort. These obfuscators who are trying to get a free ride on quantum paradoxes and quantum non-classical behaviour, at the cost of scientists and those who tirelessly abide by the difficult and no-nonsense methodology of science, generally have a very dangerous anti-enlightenment philosophico-polical agenda which they are unconsciously (what irony) pushing.

Beware of such anti-science moments and do not give credence to such mystical obscurantist interpretations.
 

What does it mean to "observe" something?

Observation is the act of using our senses to gather information about the world around us. It involves paying attention to details, making note of patterns and changes, and using our knowledge and experiences to interpret what we see.

How is observation different from other methods of gathering information?

Unlike other methods such as experimentation or surveying, observation does not involve actively manipulating or controlling variables. It is simply the act of watching and taking note of what is happening.

What are the benefits of using observation in scientific research?

Observation allows us to gather information in a natural setting, without the influence of outside factors. It also allows for the collection of data in real-time, providing more accurate and detailed information.

What are some tips for effective observation in scientific research?

Some tips for effective observation include being unbiased and objective, using multiple senses, taking detailed notes, and using tools such as cameras or recording devices to capture observations.

How can we ensure the reliability and validity of our observations?

To ensure reliability and validity, it is important to have multiple observers and to record observations consistently. It is also necessary to have a clear and specific focus for the observation and to use standardized methods for collecting and analyzing data.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
4
Replies
124
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
983
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
12
Views
860
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
817
Replies
41
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
26
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
631
Back
Top