
#19
Oct2913, 04:03 PM

P: 532

The RCD will not help the case you discussed for multiple phases or split phase with broken neutral, because all of the current returns on the normal conductors ( i.e. not ground). This type of failure is not what this protection is set to do.




#20
Oct2913, 05:11 PM

P: 2,450

Looks to me like the operation of a GFCI and an RCD is identical. However, they can be incorporated into many different devices. The most common type in the U.S. is in a receptacle. One receptacle at the beginning of the circuit can be wired to protect the rest of the circuit. The loss of a neutral between the transformer and the meter will NOT cause a GFCI incorporated into a receptacle to trip due to imbalance of current because there won't be an imbalance. The case of the GFCI built into a circuit breaker works in exactly the same way. Losing the neutral is ALWAYS bad news concerning safety as well as harming equipment. There is a good reason that the U.S. code prohibits interrupting the neutral in ALL cases. The neutral is never, ever, under any circumstance, no matter what, interrupted.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Open problem of classical representation of neutral antimatter bodies?  General Physics  6  
Determining the speed of sound from a halfopen open pipe  Introductory Physics Homework  14  
Open subset of R written as a countable union of pairwise disjoint open intervals?  Topology and Analysis  3  
Can all open sets in R^n be expressed as countable union of open cubes?  Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics  5  
Open subsets are a union of disjoint open intervals  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2 