Can elements replace Hydrogen in polar molecules & act similarly?

by joebro8659
Tags: electronegativity, elements, hydrogen, hydrogen bond, polar, polar molecules, replace, water
joebro8659 is offline
Nov4-13, 03:44 PM
P: 3
Today in 9th grade ADV Biology, we learned about how the two Hydrogen atoms in a Water molecule are relatively positive compared to the Oxygen atom. This is because the Oxygen's pull on Hydrogen's electron is greater than the Hydrogen's, or that its Electronegativity is greater. This unequal distribution in electrons is why Hydrogen is positive compared to Oxygen. Thus, they form very weak bonds, in which there is no exchange of electrons, with the negative pole of other polar molecules. This is purely the result of electrostatic attraction. This is the cause for the unusual characteristics of water, and its phases, and why things are adhesive & cohesive, as well as why our DNA is held together but split apart easily etc. I truly understand all this.

But I asked a question my teacher couldn't answer, if all this is the result of H-Bonding, and that is the result of the electronegativity of Hydrogen, than what about atoms with similar electronegativity? What if Astitane (If it wasn't radioactive) Osmium Arsenic or Phosphorus replaced the Hydrogen atoms? Would they behave similarly in a polar covalent bond with Oxygen or other atoms, as hydrogen? WOuld they partake in At-or P-Bonding for example? I'm really curios.
Phys.Org News Partner Chemistry news on
Patented research remotely detects nitrogen-rich explosives
Pocket-sized anthrax detector aids global agriculture
Structure of sodium channels different than previously believed
mfb is offline
Nov4-13, 04:00 PM
P: 10,786
Hydrogen is very small, so other atoms can come close to the effective charge. That is different for all other atoms.
They form polar covalent bonds in molecules, but they don't give the same hydrogen bonds to other molecules.

Register to reply

Related Discussions
how does non polar molecules dissolve? Chemistry 1
How to replace zeros in a matrix by elements of an array in Matlab? Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 2
Is there a way to replace nuclear power with a (big) hydrogen fuel cell General Engineering 9
Chemistry: Elements, Molecules and Bonds Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 1
Which Bond is More Polar: Carbon Hydrogen or Phospohorous Hydrogen? Chemistry 0