- #71
Physics_UG
Gold Member
- 288
- 2
I will be watching this tonight. Thanks.
DennisN said:Just stumbled upon this interview with Neil deGrasse Tyson on the new Cosmos series (I'm about to watch it):
Creationists Demand Airtime On Neil deGrasse Tyson's 'Cosmos'
Go Neal.Appearing on "The Janet Mefferd Show" on Thursday, Danny Faulkner of Answers In Genesis voiced his complaints about "Cosmos" and how the 13-episode series has described scientific theories, such as evolution, but has failed to shed light on dissenting creationist viewpoints.
Tyson recently addressed providing balance when it comes to discussing science. In an interview with CNN, the astronomer criticized the media for giving "equal time" to those who oppose widely accepted scientific theories.
"I think the media has to sort of come out of this ethos that I think was in principle a good one, but doesn't really apply in science. The ethos was, whatever story you give, you have to give the opposing view, and then you can be viewed as balanced," Tyson said, adding, "you don't talk about the spherical Earth with NASA and then say let's give equal time to the flat-earthers."
Evo said:Episode 3 is awesome, just finished watching it. Best episode so far.
Evo said:Go Neal.
The third episode was about Newton, Halley, etc... The article addresses evolution, but the third episode was excellent in talking about misguided beliefs, IMO, and I feel the article expresses my concerns that many children might be prevented from watching this series.phinds said:Evo, are you sure you are not talking about the 2nd episode ... the one pretty much completely about evolution?
I thought that was TERRIFIC, but I was not especially impressed with the 3rd episode.
I'm sadly not the least surprised. But I hope the series will have a good impact. IMHO, if "creationist groups" are becoming annoyed, the Neil is doing a good job, and a needed job.Evo said:Unfortunately 'Cosmos' doesn't seem to be sitting well with creationists and religious groups.
Yes, go Neal.Evo said:Go Neal.
DennisN said:I'm sadly not the least surprised. But I hope the series will have a good impact. IMHO, if "creationist groups" are becoming annoyed, the Neil is doing a good job, and a needed job.
This is so much more than what I expected. It's not a re-hash of the old Cosmos, they are telling stories of great moments in the history of science. I'm loving this! I wish they had explained this in the beginning, I think more people with a background in science would watch just for the stories and enjoy it.Routaran said:Just finished watching the newest episode.
I knew that NDT would be the best choice for hosting the show but each episode he's managing to reach new heights on just how brilliantly he's able to draw me in and evoke such a powerful emotional response to what I'm seeing.
Absolutely brilliant homage he paid to Sagan at the end of the episode. I'm loving every second of this show.
Evo said:This is so much more than what I expected. It's not a re-hash of the old Cosmos, they are telling stories of great moments in the history of science. I'm loving this! I wish they had explained this in the beginning, I think more people with a background in science would watch just for the stories and enjoy it.
Bandersnatch said:Hmmm, a bit too much on the speculative side, this latest one.
Bandersnatch said:Hmmm, a bit too much on the speculative side, this latest one.
Since the original Cosmos was Carl Sagan's and his wife is involved with this show, I think we can expect to see tributes to him in the series.Algr said:The Carl Sagan hero worship is getting to be a bit much. It felt right in the first two episodes, but he is overdoing it now.
Evo said:Since the original Cosmos was Carl Sagan's and his wife is involved with this show, I think we can expect to see tributes to him in the series.
collinsmark said:Just watched Season 1, episode 8. I loved it. So far I'm incredibly impressed. All the spirit of the original Cosmos, and I'm still learning good stuff. Just wonderful. I love it.