Amount of water evaporated by laser, questionable results.by Jarfi Tags: evaporated, laser, questionable, results, water 

#1
Feb1814, 11:05 AM

P: 263

Assume a laser with 30kW output energy is pointed at a boiling pot, how much water would it evaporate per second?
30kW=30kJ/s. I assume the water is at boiling point and get: Water heat of vaporization (40,65 kJ·mol−1). Thus we get: (30kJ/s)/(40,65kJ/mol)=0,74mol/s evaporated. This gives us(using the molecular mass of water) 0,74mol/s*18g/mol=13,2 g/s. Results are: 13 grams of water are evaporated per second if a 30kW laser is heating the pot. I find this very little and have assumed more water would have been evaporated, are any of these calculations wrong? 



#2
Feb1814, 11:21 AM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 1,111

That looks correct. The problem is you thinking that 13,2 g/s is not much. It is an incredibly fast evaporation: it would take 76 s to completely boil away one liter of water. Your pasta won't have time to cook!




#3
Feb1814, 11:21 AM

P: 734

Your calculations are correct.
The problem is you still don't have a good sense about units you're using. Try to "understand" what is a joule, a second, a watt! 



#4
Feb1814, 11:21 AM

P: 262

Amount of water evaporated by laser, questionable results.
I always keep in mind the order of magnitude to evaporate water: 2.5 GJ/ton = 2.5 kJ/g.
So, you are right. 



#5
Feb1814, 11:22 AM

P: 1,896

The latent heat of water is about 2.2 kJ/g.
Your laser provides 30 kJ in one second. So it may evaporate about 1314 g /s. Your calculation seems OK. But you assume that all the laser light is absorbed by water, which is questionable. The fraction absorbed depends on the wavelength of the laser. But ti is not very likely to be 100%. If it's visible light, won't be too much absorption. edit. So many people answering at the same time. 



#6
Feb1814, 11:31 AM

P: 263

It is light in the infrared to ultraviolet spektrum. I am glad my calculations are ok and fully aware that I was making assumptions, not including: Loss of power through distance traveled through air, amount of EMwaves reflected and amount of the beam that would miss the pot(depending on the distance from the laser.) Which would make even less water boil ! 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
questionable results with simulation software  Electrical Engineering  9  
deposition of salt from evaporated water  General Physics  1  
Calculations of how much water evaporated and what is left  Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework  3  
how to find amount that evaporated  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Water evaporated  General Physics  6 