Register to reply 
Is Higgs Boson Theoretical or Hypothetical? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jul1914, 07:13 AM

P: 10

I had an argument at my university about it, since experiments at LHC aren't 100% confirmed.
I mean, gauge theories are.. theories and Goldstone bosons are theorems. Someone share some light plese? 


#2
Jul1914, 08:03 AM

P: 450

Well according to wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_boson they believe they found a new particle at CERN at July 2012 that seems to be the Higgs Boson and at March 2013 they verified some of its major properties.
Not sure what you mean but everything is theory, experiments and measurements done even if they are 100% correct, they cannot prove that a theory is true, we can only say that the theory is consistent or not with the results of the experiment. If the theory is not consistent with one experiment then the theory is considered to be false. 100 experiments in consistency with a theory cannot prove the theory true, however 1 experiment inconsistent with the theory it does prove the theory false. 


#3
Jul1914, 08:58 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 16,461

1) I don't understand the distinction you are drawing between "theoretical" and "hypothetical".
2) "It's not 100% confirmed" is a terrible argument. You can say that about absolutely anything. It's not 100% certain that my neighbor won't turn into a werewolf tonight and kill me. But I don't live my life as if it were a serious concern. 3) There is no reasonable doubt that a particle was discovered at the LHC. This particle has the properties of the SM Higgs to within one's ability to measure. 


#4
Jul1914, 11:27 AM

Mentor
P: 11,862

Is Higgs Boson Theoretical or Hypothetical?
In particle physics, the convention is to announce that a new particle has been discovered only when the evidence reaches a "fivesigma" level. This means that if the particle did not actually exist, then there would be a probability of less than ##3 \times 10^{7}## that the data came out that way by chance. 5 Sigma—What’s That? 


#5
Jul1914, 12:27 PM

P: 10

So are we on fivesigma level? 


#6
Jul1914, 03:04 PM

Mentor
P: 12,037




#7
Jul1914, 03:32 PM

P: 1,021

Had they really reached 5 sigmas? I thought they were at 3 until LHC reruns... Nice clarification



#8
Jul1914, 03:34 PM

P: 1,021

Also what does the OP mean by gauge theories are just theories?
We are pretty sure that the way to explain elementary particle interactions is through gauge theories... 


#9
Jul1914, 04:06 PM

Mentor
P: 11,862

As I recall, there are "Higgsless" electroweak theories, but preHiggsdiscovery they didn't match experimental data as "naturally" as the standard model with Higgs. 


#10
Jul1914, 04:14 PM

P: 10

Nop, I meant theory in the scence of the math definition for theory or theorem, which is good.
I'm a mathematician by the way :). 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Is the higgs boson the mediator of the higgs field?  High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics  31  
What does it mean, The Higgs boson is an excitation of the higgs field  High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics  11  
If the Boson Higgs Boson only exists for >.< long...  High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics  1  
Higgs boson  High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics  9  
Could it be that Higgs's boson does not exist, but Higgs mechanism does?  Beyond the Standard Model  14 