- #1
tgt
- 522
- 2
Is it better to have a Phd supervisor who've just finished their postdoc? Or someone who is established in the field as a professor? Or someone in between? Have a vote.
JasonJo said:I think there are two sides to this question:
1) Which type of professor will help you write the best possible thesis?
2) Which type of professor will help you get a nice postdoc after graduation?
There are some people you might mesh with very well but they do not have the connections or stature of a more established professor.
It really is up to you. Personally, I say go with the professor who will help you write the best possible thesis and become the best possible research mathematician (or scientist depending on your field).
jostpuur said:Could it also become a problem, that old guys are not so well suited to understanding new things?
It has happened to me, that I've successfully explained something to some young grad student (I'm undergrad myself), but I've been strangely unable to explain the same to an old professor. Sometimes I feel that the communication just works better with young guys
A Phd supervisor is responsible for guiding and supporting a Phd student throughout their research journey. They provide mentorship, offer advice and feedback on research ideas, and help the student develop their skills and knowledge in their field of study.
A Professor is a senior academic with extensive research experience and a strong publication record. They often have a busy schedule and may have multiple Phd students under their supervision. A Postdoc is a recent Phd graduate who is pursuing further research experience before starting a faculty position. They may have more time to dedicate to a Phd student but may have less experience in supervising. An In-Between Phd supervisor is typically a mid-career academic who may have a good balance of experience and availability to supervise a Phd student.
Choosing a Phd supervisor is a personal decision and depends on your research interests, goals, and working style. It is important to research and reach out to potential supervisors to discuss your research ideas and expectations. You can also ask for recommendations from current or former Phd students and consider their experiences with the supervisor.
When considering different Phd supervisors, you should think about their research expertise and publications, their availability and workload, their supervision style, and their track record of successfully supervising Phd students to completion. It is also important to consider their personality and whether you think you can have a good working relationship with them.
Yes, it is possible to have co-supervisors for your Phd. This can be beneficial as it provides you with different perspectives and expertise. However, it is important to have clear communication and expectations between all supervisors to ensure a successful working relationship.