Why does democracy work so well?

  • News
  • Thread starter MaxManus
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Work
In summary: Basically, democracy doesn't work so well because most people are not smart or interested enough to make good decisions. China is doing a better job because their citizens are intelligent and interested in their government." Basically, democracy doesn't work so well because most people are not smart or interested enough to make good decisions. China is doing a better job because their citizens are intelligent and interested in their government.
  • #36
Anything larger than a town has to have a representative democracy, or there'd be no way to govern. A democratic system must be structured to protect the majority from the minority and the minority from the majority.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #37
CAC1001 said:
Anything larger than a town has to have a representative democracy, or there'd be no way to govern. A democratic system must be structured to protect the majority from the minority and the minority from the majority.

I would assume that the internet changes all that. I see no reason (besides ideaology) why a "perfect" democracy would be intangible in the next 100 years, even for a country as large as the United States.
 
  • #38
I agree with CAC1001, and there also is the answer to the OP. If the masses really did control the US (and that's how things have been heading), you'd have the mess we are in now. The worst possible outcome for the US would be control by Facebook. The OP was correct when he alluded to idiots and ignorants running the show. But, we've watered down our representative democracy over the course of 200 years and now have almost-direct election of the President (used to be done by state Senates), mandatory-minimum sentencing, elected judges, and other follies. And a big mess.

BTW Alexander Hamilton expressed dire concern over control by the mob, and it's him you can largely thank for keeping our experiment from toppling over much quicker than it appears to be doing right now.

Long term, I envision a return to a more representative form of government. Don't ask me how that will happen.

Oh yeah, here's why it has to happen. Because if it doesn't, we're screwed.
 
  • #39
Democracy is the government of the people, by the people and for the people.That's probably why it works
 
  • #40
jennex05 said:
Democracy is the government of the people, by the people and for the people.That's probably why it works
Come now, the US is not an example of government of, by, and for the people. It's, essentially, an oligarchy -- government of, by, and for the rich. But the US is incredibly weathy. So, there's lots to go around, and virtually the entire population lives in relative comfort.

It has little to do with 'democracy', imo.
 
  • #41
Constantin said:
But democracy has many flaws and doesn't always work.
More important than democracy is the economic capitalist system. The opposite is the state run communist system which proved to be a dead end, and which now only exists in North Korea.

Democracy doesn't work well with poverty.
In the third world there's a large number of countries which are not democracies.

It also might not be best suited for large countries with plenty of internal problems, like Russia or China.
Russia has something in between democracy and dictatorship, while China has a single party non democratic system.
Both however are capitalist countries.

So, in conclusion, there's a large number of cases where democracy doesn't work, and a large number where it does.
As the users of this forum are mostly from democratic countries, we might have a biased opinion about it.

And my conclusion is the same ,even India has internal problems.
naxals
A democratic government is too sympathetic ,it can't take quick and sharp actions in case of internal security and maintaining unity.

The reason why China is so successful is because it could force people out of agriculture and into Industry and manufacturing and so the income levels came up,where as in India you have to persuade people ,that doesn't always works because you can't reason with uneducated people.
 
  • #42
I think that democracy works because it offers ways of defusing political tensions. Without democracy, one has such alternatives as revolution or heavyhanded repression.

Republics can very from a democratic republic (representative democracy) to an oligarchic republic, like the former Republic of Venice and most Communist countries.

Republicanism is sometimes contrasted with monarchy, but there are part-republic and part-monarchy systems, usually a monarch coexisting with an elected council or legislature. Several present-day "monarchies" may better be described as crowned republics, republics in just about everything but name. The monarchs and royal families are essentially professional socialites and professional celebrities.
 
<h2>1. Why is democracy considered the best form of government?</h2><p>Democracy is considered the best form of government because it allows for equal representation and participation of all citizens in decision-making processes. This ensures that the needs and interests of the majority are taken into account, leading to a more fair and just society.</p><h2>2. How does democracy promote individual rights and freedoms?</h2><p>Democracy promotes individual rights and freedoms by guaranteeing basic human rights such as freedom of speech, religion, and assembly. In a democratic society, citizens have the right to express their opinions and beliefs without fear of persecution, and the government is accountable to the people for upholding these rights.</p><h2>3. What role does education play in a successful democracy?</h2><p>Education plays a crucial role in a successful democracy as it allows citizens to make informed decisions and participate actively in the democratic process. A well-educated population is more likely to understand complex issues, critically evaluate information, and hold their government accountable for its actions.</p><h2>4. How does democracy promote economic prosperity?</h2><p>Democracy promotes economic prosperity by creating a stable and predictable environment for businesses to thrive. In a democratic society, there are laws and regulations in place to protect property rights and ensure fair competition, which encourages innovation and entrepreneurship. Additionally, a government that is accountable to its citizens is more likely to make policies that benefit the economy as a whole.</p><h2>5. What are the potential challenges to democracy?</h2><p>Some potential challenges to democracy include corruption, political polarization, and lack of participation and engagement from citizens. Corruption can undermine the fairness and integrity of the democratic process, while political polarization can lead to gridlock and hinder progress. Additionally, when citizens are apathetic or disengaged, it can weaken the effectiveness of democracy as a form of government.</p>

1. Why is democracy considered the best form of government?

Democracy is considered the best form of government because it allows for equal representation and participation of all citizens in decision-making processes. This ensures that the needs and interests of the majority are taken into account, leading to a more fair and just society.

2. How does democracy promote individual rights and freedoms?

Democracy promotes individual rights and freedoms by guaranteeing basic human rights such as freedom of speech, religion, and assembly. In a democratic society, citizens have the right to express their opinions and beliefs without fear of persecution, and the government is accountable to the people for upholding these rights.

3. What role does education play in a successful democracy?

Education plays a crucial role in a successful democracy as it allows citizens to make informed decisions and participate actively in the democratic process. A well-educated population is more likely to understand complex issues, critically evaluate information, and hold their government accountable for its actions.

4. How does democracy promote economic prosperity?

Democracy promotes economic prosperity by creating a stable and predictable environment for businesses to thrive. In a democratic society, there are laws and regulations in place to protect property rights and ensure fair competition, which encourages innovation and entrepreneurship. Additionally, a government that is accountable to its citizens is more likely to make policies that benefit the economy as a whole.

5. What are the potential challenges to democracy?

Some potential challenges to democracy include corruption, political polarization, and lack of participation and engagement from citizens. Corruption can undermine the fairness and integrity of the democratic process, while political polarization can lead to gridlock and hinder progress. Additionally, when citizens are apathetic or disengaged, it can weaken the effectiveness of democracy as a form of government.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
10
Views
7K
  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
908
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
605
Replies
6
Views
899
  • STEM Academic Advising
3
Replies
92
Views
3K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
842
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
1K
Back
Top