Why We Need Calculus for Mechatronics Studies

In summary: Because the mass is changing, the acceleration is changing, and the force (push or pull) is also changing.
  • #1
Femme_physics
Gold Member
2,550
1
Mechatronics course..someone asked me "why do we need to study calculus".how to reply

So we're mechatronics 1st year, we're about to start our second semester just having finished statics WITHOUT calculus. I presume this semester we're starting on Calculus. My classmate grudgingly asked me why do we even need to study calculus. Now, I know that Calculus is the math of change, but I'm not sure how to give him a proper reply as we haven't practiced the use of calculus and how it applies to machines or mechatronics. Can you guys give me a reply I can have for him?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2


Because if you don't, your future classes will be much harder if not impossible.
 
  • #3


The most obvious application of calculus in mechanics is what happens when things change with time. In other words, when things move. The general term for that study is dynamics, compared with statics. If you want to study anything that moves with varying speed, or which changes direction as it moves, you can't get very far without using calculus. In fact in Newton's law of motion which says "force equals rate of change of momentum", the words "rate of change" are a good indication that calculus is involved. (You may have met that law as "force = mass x acceleration", which is the special case where the mass of the object remains constant. Even then, acceleration is the rate of change of velocity over time)

Calculus is also useful for many problems in statics, when quantites vary not with time but with the position in the object. For example, a rod or a beam where the cross section tapers along its length, or the pressure load on an object in a fluid which depends on the depth, such as the force on the face of a dam, or the side of a ship.
 
  • #4


Mechatronics and calculus huh?

Well

Control Theory
Statistics for manufacturing and quality control
Hydraulics/pneumatics
Cam /tappet/tool theory
Your own self esteem when talking to engineers in other disciplines

go well
 
  • #5


AlephZero said:
The most obvious application of calculus in mechanics is what happens when things change with time. In other words, when things move. The general term for that study is dynamics, compared with statics. If you want to study anything that moves with varying speed, or which changes direction as it moves, you can't get very far without using calculus. In fact in Newton's law of motion which says "force equals rate of change of momentum", the words "rate of change" are a good indication that calculus is involved. (You may have met that law as "force = mass x acceleration", which is the special case where the mass of the object remains constant. Even then, acceleration is the rate of change of velocity over time)

Calculus is also useful for many problems in statics, when quantites vary not with time but with the position in the object. For example, a rod or a beam where the cross section tapers along its length, or the pressure load on an object in a fluid which depends on the depth, such as the force on the face of a dam, or the side of a ship.

Perfect answer :) thanks...I'll make sure he gets this. The idea in giving him a proper reply after all is not to make him feel lousy (I could've come up with fss's reply), but to make him understand the functional use of it. But thanks to the others.
 
  • #6


(You may have met that law as "force = mass x acceleration", which is the special case where the mass of the object remains constant. Even then, acceleration is the rate of change of velocity over time)

When an object mass in constant it's a special case?!? Isn't that the other way around?.. .I'm confused.

Calculus is also useful for many problems in statics, when quantites vary not with time but with the position in the object.

But objects don't move in statics
 
Last edited:
  • #7


So..
I took ME 454/Mechatronics in college a few years ago.

When we were programming a rotating arm robot to land at a desired coordinate... everyone had trouble with it. Because the C++/microcontroller limited us to using linear equations only. And you were trying to compensate for friction, which is non-linear on the rotating arm, for where it would land.

Using calculus, you can dead on hit that spot, since you can calculate and adjust in real time.


That's a good example of why calculus is necessary.

Calculus allows us to get definite answers, not linear approximations.

And if the above fails, because I said so, and you have to pass my class.
 
  • #8


Femme_physics said:
When an object mass in constant it's a special case?!? Isn't that the other way around?.. .I'm confused.



But objects don't move in statics


No, think of airplanes. The mass is constantly changing as the engines burn fuel.
 
  • #9


Ah... I see. Thanks batman :)
 
  • #10


Another good example, asteroid masses falling to Earth. As they go through the atmosphere, they burn up and get smaller.

And you never have to thank me.
 
  • #11


Femme_physics said:
When an object mass in constant it's a special case?!? Isn't that the other way around?.. .I'm confused.
You are confusing the differencce between the general case (the mass varies) and a special case (the mass is constant), with the most common case, which depends what area of engineering you are working in. For example if you are dealing with rocket launching, the mass of the rocket always changes, as it burns fuel.

But objects don't move in statics
Flexible objects do "move", or at least they change shape, under static loads. (Look carefully at your car tires and see if they are really "round" when they are supporting the weight of the car). In a first non-calculus course you may have only considered situations where you assume all the objects are rigid.

For example a cantilever beam bends into a curved shape when it is loaded. The amount of curvature at any point depends on the bending moment at that point (and also the shape of the cross section of the beam, the materal it is made from, etc). If there is a single force applied at the end of the beam, the bending moment changes along the length. The curvature is also related (by geometry) to the second derivative of the beam's displacement. So calculus comes into this sort of statics problem in several different ways.
 
Last edited:
  • #12


So calculus comes into this sort of statics problem in several different ways.

Very good point I missed from my list.
 
  • #13


AlephZero said:
You are confusing the differencce between the general case (the mass varies) and a special case (the mass is constant), with the most common case, which depends what area of engineering you are working in. For example if you are dealing with rocket launching, the mass of the rocket always changes, as it burns fuel. Flexible objects do "move", or at least they change shape, under static loads. (Look carefully at your car tires and see if they are really "round" when they are supporting the weight of the car). In a first non-calculus course you may have only considered situations where you assume all the objects are rigid.

For example a cantilever beam bends into a curved shape when it is loaded. The amount of curvature at any point depends on the bending moment at that point (and also the shape of the cross section of the beam, the materal it is made from, etc). If there is a single force applied at the end of the beam, the bending moment changes along the length. The curvature is also related (by geometry) to the second derivative of the beam's displacement. So calculus comes into this sort of statics problem in several different ways.

Oooh...great insight :) You're right, we've always assumed bodies are rigid. This is going to get more interesting, though :D
 
  • #14


hi I am new !

just curious wut U do you go to? I was trying to get into mechatronics but my school don't offer it so now I am just double major in ME and EE.and yea I would say Calculus is the algebra of continuous change, EG when you have a constant acceleration your speed is continuously changing right? what can you say about the change in displacement without knowing the idea of integral? as the matter of fact the kinematic equations are all derivation of the differential form of F=ma, which is F = dp/dt. you going to need it as you move on to higher level physics.

I took statics last quarter and now I am in dynamics, and I wonder if you guys cover moment of inertia or centroid in statics? I think that required calculus too didn't it?wish you luck in mechatronics!
 
  • #15


Thanks, TheAnswer! I was about to look at center of gravity as we'll be studying it this semester. Yes, it's covered in statics and I'm quite sure we'll learn it before dynamics.
 
  • #16


Femme_physics said:
Thanks, TheAnswer! I was about to look at center of gravity as we'll be studying it this semester. Yes, it's covered in statics and I'm quite sure we'll learn it before dynamics.


no problem! so what's your math level? if you are learning cal next semester and this is your first year I think you are on track, there are only a couple left after cal and it's not that hard! don't be intimidated! study well my friend for your future!
 
  • #17


:) I am, I am giving my all and hold this course, physics, and math as the most important things in the world to me (sorry mom, dad, bf...).

My math level is good when it comes to algebraic manipulations, basics of logs, and trigonometry. We haven't touched matrices, complex numbers, or anything that we don't really need for statics and to solve for 3 unknowns..really basic stuff.

The problem that the math teacher told me that we're only studying the "basics" of calculus, so I don't really know how far we'd go. But, loving every little bit of math and physics I get, (and chemistry!) and devouring it!
 

1. Why is calculus important for mechatronics studies?

Calculus is important for mechatronics studies because it is the foundation for understanding and analyzing complex systems and their behavior. Mechatronics involves the integration of mechanical, electrical, and computer engineering, and calculus is used to model and analyze the dynamics and control of these systems.

2. How does calculus relate to mechatronics?

Calculus is used in mechatronics to study the rate of change of physical quantities, such as speed, acceleration, and force, which are essential for understanding the behavior and control of mechatronic systems. It is also used to develop mathematical models that describe the behavior of these systems and their components.

3. Can I learn mechatronics without knowing calculus?

While it is possible to learn the basics of mechatronics without knowing calculus, a more advanced understanding of the subject requires a strong foundation in calculus. Many concepts in mechatronics, such as system dynamics, control theory, and optimization, heavily rely on calculus for their formulation and analysis.

4. What specific topics in calculus are important for mechatronics studies?

The most important topics in calculus for mechatronics studies include derivatives, integrals, differential equations, and multivariable calculus. These concepts are used to analyze the behavior of mechatronic systems, design control algorithms, and optimize system performance.

5. How can learning calculus benefit a career in mechatronics?

A strong understanding of calculus is essential for a successful career in mechatronics. It enables engineers to accurately model and analyze complex systems, design and implement control strategies, and optimize system performance. Understanding calculus also allows engineers to communicate and collaborate effectively with other professionals in the field.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
45
Views
4K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
15
Views
326
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
10
Views
838
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
10
Views
5K
Replies
10
Views
1K
Back
Top