Exploring Quantum Gravity: Conservation Theory & Gravitons

In summary, the conversation discussed the relationship between quantum gravity and gravitons, and whether or not bodies of matter need to consume energy/mass to create gravitons, in consideration of the Conservation Theory. The group also questioned if photons can be considered as "popping out of nowhere" and discussed the concept of massless particles and their ability to create gravitational fields.
  • #1
LF_Ent
7
0
If quantum gravity exists, then gravitons are responsible; however, it seems to me as if a body of matter would need to be consuming energy/mass (as the sun does) to create gravitons, because of the Conservation Theory. Have I overlooked something? Almost certainly, but I cannot find it. Any help is much appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Recall that electrons do not "consume" mass nor charge in producing photons.
 
  • #3
LF_Ent said:
If quantum gravity exists, then gravitons are responsible; however, it seems to me as if a body of matter would need to be consuming energy/mass (as the sun does) to create gravitons, because of the Conservation Theory. Have I overlooked something? Almost certainly, but I cannot find it. Any help is much appreciated.
If you describe electromagnetism or gravity in terms of virtually exchanged massless bosons, then those bosons can not strictly be on-shell. They are (maybe very slightly, but in any case) virtual. The classical force arises from the interference between no boson exchange and (at least one) boson exchange.
 
  • #4
So wouldn't that also break Conservation Theory? After all, the photons can't be popping out of nowhere. Mass and energy can't be created or destroyed, but only change form, right?
 
  • #5
LF_Ent said:
So wouldn't that also break Conservation Theory? After all, the photons can't be popping out of nowhere. Mass and energy can't be created or destroyed, but only change form, right?
Wrong (sorry :smile:). You can not enforce conservation laws to better than Heisenberg inequalities.
 
  • #6
Oh, okay. Thanks.

(Just so you know, when I made my second post I hadn't seen yours; I wasn't ignoring you = P)
 
  • #7
k i might be way off and my physics background is limited , if light creates a gravitational
field then does this mean that a graviton is inside the photon.?
 
  • #8
No, any more than the fact that accelerated electrons can emit photons means that the photons were inside the electron to begin with.
 
  • #9
cragar said:
k i might be way off and my physics background is limited , if light creates a gravitational
field then does this mean that a graviton is inside the photon.?

It seems to me that since the photon is massless, it has no gravitational influence. But these people seem to be much more educated than me. = P
 
  • #10
the photon is massless but still creates a gravitational field . Newtons 3rd law.
if light can be bent in a gravitational field then the light has an equal but opposite reaction. and another way we can show that light creates gravity is that if we had
matter and antimatter in a sealed can with mirrors when the matter and anti matter collided they would produce photons and the gravitational field would still be there it wouldn't dissappear.
 
  • #11
massles particles have energy...they can do work...and from Einstein we know that mass and energy are different aspects of a common entity...both produce gravitational effects and respond to them...hence light is bent in a gravitational field ...as was initially the proof of general relativity by Arthur Eddington...that made Einstein a household name...
 
  • #12
Well, what do you expect from someone whose IQ is smaller than their age?:tongue:
 
  • #13
humanino said:
Wrong (sorry :smile:). You can not enforce conservation laws to better than Heisenberg inequalities.

Four-momentum is exactly conserved at all points in Feynman diagrams (even including loops) :smile:
 
  • #14
nrqed said:
Four-momentum is exactly conserved at all points in Feynman diagrams (even including loops) :smile:
Yes, that's true. That does not change anything to the answer I provided though ! The size of quantum fluctuations, as described by Feynman diagrams, can be estimated from the Heisenberg inequalities. This is done at the level of Halzen and Martin textbook for instance.
 

1. What is quantum gravity?

Quantum gravity is a theoretical framework that aims to reconcile the principles of quantum mechanics and general relativity. It seeks to explain the fundamental nature of gravity at the subatomic level.

2. What is conservation theory in quantum gravity?

Conservation theory in quantum gravity refers to the principle that certain quantities, such as energy and momentum, are conserved in physical systems. This means that they cannot be created or destroyed, but can only be transferred or transformed.

3. What are gravitons?

Gravitons are hypothetical particles that are thought to be the carriers of the gravitational force in quantum gravity. They are predicted by certain quantum gravity theories, such as string theory, but have not yet been observed experimentally.

4. How does quantum gravity affect our understanding of the universe?

Quantum gravity has the potential to significantly change our understanding of the universe by providing a more complete and unified description of the fundamental forces and particles. It could also help explain phenomena such as black holes and the origins of the universe.

5. Is there any evidence for quantum gravity?

At this time, there is no direct evidence for quantum gravity. However, some of its predictions, such as the existence of gravitons, are being explored through experiments in particle physics and cosmology. Further research and experimentation are needed to confirm the validity of quantum gravity theories.

Similar threads

  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
6
Views
582
Replies
16
Views
989
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
776
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top