Moving on from Single Variable to Multivariable Calculus: Marsden or Stewart?

  • Thread starter physicsnoob93
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Guidance
In summary, the author is considering moving on to multivariable calculus and is unsure if they have a strong enough foundation in single variable calculus. They want to know if it is ok to do this without having completed a rigorous course in single variable calculus. They also want to know if there is anything that can help them speed up the process.
  • #1
physicsnoob93
169
0
Hello everyone.

I needed some guidance with calculus. I am currently a (sophomore? Sorry, I'm not following the US system) and I used stewart's book to learn single variable calculus, but I didn't do the exercises from the book, and I did the exercises at the AP level. I took my AP Calculus BC today. Although I'm hoping for a 5, I think I have the concepts but it's not entirely concrete yet.

My question is: I want to move on and learn multivariable calculus starting the end of May, probably continuing Stewart's or using Marsden. Do you think it's ok for me to do this without having a very rigorous base in single variable calculus?

And also, I know there have been many threads on this, but still, Marsden or Stewart? They both look very similar to me.

Thanks.

Edit: Oh, and to add. I am not doing all this preparation for pure math (Plan to do EE&CS). I am doing this for physics, because I enjoy physics.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If you're not completely comfortable with single variable calculus, it would be better to study that more thoroughly before you start multivariable calculus. It's better to have a solid foundation rather than patchy knowledge of many things.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Any way to do that quick? Because each chapter in stewart has a hundred exercises. And i don't want to go through all of that for like 11 chapters. :

Is there anything that will help me get around this?

Thanks
 
  • #4
physicsnoob93 said:
Any way to do that quick? Because each chapter in stewart has a hundred exercises. And i don't want to go through all of that for like 11 chapters. :

There's no "quick" way of learning mathematics. The only way to learn, is to do.
 
  • #5
Also, there's no need to do every single exercise that is given in your book. Do as many as you need to to learn the material and feel comfortable.
 
  • #6
physicsnoob93 said:
Any way to do that quick? Because each chapter in stewart has a hundred exercises. And i don't want to go through all of that for like 11 chapters. :

Is there anything that will help me get around this?

Thanks
You don't need to do all 100 for every chapter, though - a typical college math course might assign 5-10 every week (well, it depends on what kind of problems they are).
 
  • #7
You should also solve some problems in the the "problems plus" sections which have more challenging problems.
 
  • #8
Will it be effective to skip the "Section" problems and jump right into the problems at the end of the chapter summary + problems plus? That would save loads of time.

Appreciate the input.
 
  • #9
Just want you to remind you that you essentially need to pass the AP Calc exam (get about 60% of the test right) to get a 5. Hence, you should judge your own level of comfort with the concepts partly based on the exam. If you think you could have done or did complete most of the problems on the exam, you should be in good shape to tackle a book such as stewart's MV calc. But if there were many concepts that you skimped over, then go through stewart's single var text again. Judge for yourself where your weaknesses are and remedy them if necessary.

But if you already know you need to work through Stewart single var, you should still judge for yourself which exercises are necessary. Most of the exercises are a lot like the examples in the chapter, so don't do the ones where it is immediately clear how to proceed with a solution. Don't solely focus on the problems plus section, because there are genuinely difficult problems there, not all of which will be particularly relevant for your purposes. Most importantly, don't rush ahead. Why so hurried?
 
  • #10
To snipez, yeah I know the Calculus BC material throughout and I expect a 5. It's just that I don't think calculus BC is enough to continue to multivariate calculus. I think something deeper is required to understand it better. Obviously, the things covered in stewarts book are probably a level higher than the BC material. And yeah I'm doing this not because I want to hurry. It's just that school isn't very challenging. We're still doing sequences and binomial theorem fgs. Also, I want to learn E and M to a higher level with vector analysis.
 

1. What is the purpose of "A little guidance, please?"

The purpose of "A little guidance, please?" is to provide individuals with advice and direction in their personal or professional lives.

2. Who can benefit from "A little guidance, please?"

Anyone who is seeking guidance or direction in their life can benefit from "A little guidance, please?". This can include students, professionals, or anyone facing a difficult decision or challenge.

3. What kind of guidance is offered in "A little guidance, please?"

The guidance offered in "A little guidance, please?" can vary depending on the specific situation, but it generally includes strategies for problem-solving, decision-making, and personal growth. It may also include tips for improving communication and building healthy relationships.

4. How can I access "A little guidance, please?"

"A little guidance, please?" can be accessed through various mediums such as books, online resources, workshops, or through working with a professional coach or mentor.

5. Is "A little guidance, please?" effective?

The effectiveness of "A little guidance, please?" depends on the individual and their willingness to implement the guidance provided. However, many people have found success and improvement in their lives through following the advice and strategies offered in "A little guidance, please?".

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
1
Views
993
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
898
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top