Does a constant electric flux produce a current?

In summary: Clem is correct here, you used Gauss' Law to relate the charge to the electric field, but Gauss' law requires a closed surface and since you have a spacially constant electric field you will always have zero flux.
  • #1
eoghan
207
7
Hi! Suppose I have a wire with a potential difference V=bx where b is a constant. Then there is an electric field which is constant: E=b through out the wire. Well, now consider this relation:
[tex]I=\frac{dq}{dt}=\frac{d}{dt}\epsilon_0\int{\vec{E}\cdot\hat{n}dS}=\epsilon_0 S \frac{dE}{dt}=0[/tex]
where I used the Gauss' theorem and the fact that E is constant.
From this relation then follows that the electric current is 0! But I do have an electric current in the wire! Where am I wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
What surface are you integrating over, what does "x" stand for? Could you explain the problem a little more so that I can help you, personally I can't see it. Thanks
 
  • #3
Your Gaussian surface must be closed. The current flows in one side and out the other, which is why the integral is zero.
 
  • #4
Zaphys said:
What surface are you integrating over, what does "x" stand for? Could you explain the problem a little more so that I can help you, personally I can't see it. Thanks

Let's say that the wire lies along the x axis.. then x represents a point of the wire. I integrate over a surface perpendicular to the wire in a point x with the center on the wire. But the surface is meaningless, what matters is that if E is constant in time, then its flux will be constant in time (if the surface is constant in time).

clem said:
The current flows in one side and out the other, which is why the integral is zero.
Yes, but if you define I=dq/dt then you have I=d/dt (flux(E)) which is zero. With the Gauss' theorem I don't get the net current in the surface (which is zero), but the charge.
 
  • #5
Have it your way, but I thought you said "I used the Gauss' theorem".
 
  • #6
eoghan said:
Let's say that the wire lies along the x axis.. then x represents a point of the wire. I integrate over a surface perpendicular to the wire in a point x with the center on the wire. But the surface is meaningless, what matters is that if E is constant in time, then its flux will be constant in time (if the surface is constant in time).


Yes, but if you define I=dq/dt then you have I=d/dt (flux(E)) which is zero. With the Gauss' theorem I don't get the net current in the surface (which is zero), but the charge.

clem is correct here, you used Gauss' Law to relate the charge to the electric field, but Gauss' law requires a closed surface and since you have a spacially constant electric field you will always have zero flux. You should instead try the Lorentz force, however, you would need knowledge of the saturation velocity of charges, otherwise the constant force over an infinite wire will create infinite current.

Still, in respect to your original question, yes, a constant flux can create current. I know that in a simple MOSFET model, we assume that there is a constant electric field between the source and drain which results in a current. The amount of current is limited by the finite cross-sectional area of the transistor, the finite length of the transistor, and the finite saturation velocity of the mobile carriers.
 

1. What is a constant electric flux?

A constant electric flux is the measure of electric field passing through a given area. It is represented by the symbol Φ and is measured in units of volts.

2. How does a constant electric flux produce a current?

A constant electric flux can produce a current when there is a change in the electric field over time. This change in electric field creates a force on the charges in the circuit, causing them to move and producing a current.

3. What factors affect the production of current from a constant electric flux?

The production of current from a constant electric flux is affected by the strength of the electric field, the presence of conductive materials, and the resistance of the circuit.

4. Can a constant electric flux produce a current in a vacuum?

No, a constant electric flux cannot produce a current in a vacuum because there are no charged particles present to be affected by the electric field.

5. How is a constant electric flux different from a varying electric flux?

A constant electric flux remains the same over time, while a varying electric flux changes in magnitude and direction. A varying electric flux can produce a current, while a constant electric flux can only produce a current when there is a change in the electric field.

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
844
Replies
3
Views
696
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
30
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
16
Views
989
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
663
  • Sticky
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
1
Views
673
Back
Top