Register to reply 
Inverse Square Law 
Share this thread: 
#1
Mar2814, 07:32 PM

P: 2

I found this forum on Google. This may not be the right section so excuse me if so. I have a rather simple question though.
When you take a magnifying glass on a sunny day and position it just right over a piece of paper, the paper will start to burn. Is the inverse square law (distance) the biggest factor at play in getting the paper to burn? Or is it more that due to the way the lens is positioned, it concentrates the light into a single point rather than diffuse it? 


#2
Mar2814, 07:42 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 3,495

The simple form of the inverse square law describes what happens to light propagating freely away from its source and dispersing as it goes. When you add a lens into the picture, it no longer applies. 


#3
Mar2814, 07:48 PM

P: 2

On a camera, the focal length of a lens (how close/far the lens is from the film) has something to do with the amount of light that hits the frame of film. Is that because of the inverse square law?



#4
Mar2814, 08:35 PM

P: 289

Inverse Square Law



#5
Mar2814, 11:55 PM

P: 356

The inverse square law is a manifestation of spherical symmetry.



#6
Mar2914, 04:38 AM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 11,958

Burning or not will depend on several factors. The area of the lens will determine how much solar radiation is captured (based on 1kW per meter squared  which is determined by the ISL but is the same for all lenses in clear sunlight).
The temperature of the hot spot will depend on its size (the optics) and the rate at which heat is conducted away from the spot. A thin piece of paper, protected from drafts will burn easier than a fat piece of cardboard (or metal). 


#7
Mar2914, 05:17 AM

P: 697

Adding to what others have said, the inverse square law would have a role to play if you were trying to burn the paper using e.g., a naked lighbulb. Since we can approximately treat the bulb as a point source radiating in all directions, the farther you get from it the less energy you catch.
When treated as one, a lens is a completely different kind of source. It most definitely does not radiate equally in all directions, so inverse square law does not apply. There are other kinds of light sources that do not obey the inverse square relationship. Think of a prefectly collimated laser beam  no matter how far you get from the source, you get the same amount of energy per area. In principle, the inverse square law does play a role when trying to burn something with a lens in the sense that as you position the lens closer to the Sun, it catches a bit more of its energy than if you put farther away(i.e., closer to the ground). That's because the Sun does radiate (approximatelly)equally in all directions, so the amount of incident energy does fall as a square of the distance. Of course, since the change of distance of a few centimetres, or even thousands of kilometres, is so minuscle as compared to the distance from the Sun, the difference in received light is absolutely and completely negligible(so it's perfectly safe to assume the energy received from the Sun on Earth is independent of distance, and all light rays coming from it are parallel). 


#8
Mar2914, 07:34 AM

P: 289

All else being equal (equal sized lens, equal distance from light source, equal distance from lens to film.), the focal length of the lens does not change the amount of light that hits the film as long as the film is large enough to catch all the light and nothing else blocks it. Focal length only changes how the light is focused.



#9
Mar3014, 12:50 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 11,958




#10
Apr114, 06:41 AM

P: 697

Huh. Thanks sophiecentaur, I see now how one does not necessarily follow from the other.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
To prove right inverse implies left inverse for square matrices.  Calculus & Beyond Homework  15  
Inverse square law  General Physics  5  
Magnetic field strength diminishes proportional to inverse cube or inverse square?  General Physics  5  
Inversesquare law  General Physics  8  
Inverse Square Law  Introductory Physics Homework  2 