Exploring Our Solar System: Gas and Debris

In summary, the conversation discusses the appearance and composition of interstellar clouds and their effects on the solar system. It is explained that the bright swirls seen in pictures of galaxies are actually concentrations of stars, while images of interstellar gas are enhanced and colorized. The conversation also explores how the density of the interstellar medium affects its appearance, with thicker clouds appearing more fuzzy and cloudy. The typical density of interstellar gas is one particle per cubic centimeter, and it can appear reflective in images. The clouds do move relative to us, but their side-to-side motion is difficult to measure.
  • #1
jhe1984
100
0
Okay,

Looking at pictures of other galaxies - and representations of our own - each spiral arm seems surrounded in huge clouds and bright swirls. I am presumbing this is some sort of illuminated gas and debris, but here's my question:

If our solar system is on one indiscriminate spiral arm, how come these huge bright clouds of interstellar and gas don't come drifting through our neck of the woods?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
jhe1984 said:
If our solar system is on one indiscriminate spiral arm, how come these huge bright clouds of interstellar and gas don't come drifting through our neck of the woods?

They almost certainly do, from time to time, but these clouds are not nearly as dense as you might think. I don't know exactly which ones you're talking about, but the typical densities in the interstellar medium are about a particle per cubic centimeter and the maximum densities are around [itex]10^6[/itex] molecules per cubic centimeter.

For comparison, the air you're breating has of order [itex]10^{19}[/itex] molecules per cubic centimeter.
 
  • #3
Wow, I can't believe there are measurements for this sort of thing!

But I don't understand why the interstellar medium would "look" like clouds far away, but not close up?

It seems like if they looked like anything it would be like a sort of illuminated asteroid belt.

Also, was that a typo or did you really say that the low end of the range of the interstellar medium (this is the stuff we see as 'inside' a galaxy, as opposed to empty space, right?) is one PARTICLE per cubic centimeter? Whoa. And that's reflective?

One more question, do these "space clouds" appear (on whatever spectrum) moving relative to us, like Earth clouds relative to the ground?

Thanks!
 
  • #4
Before we get too far, we should figure out what it is you're seeing.

If you're looking at pictures of galaxies, and you're seeing "huge clouds and bright swirls", I would strongly suspect that those are concentrations of stars, not clouds of gas.


Certainly, there's lot of pics of interstellar gas, and that may be what you're looking at - but something to factor in here is that those exposures are greatly, greatly, enhanced, contrasted and colourized (often false colour) to make the detail stand out.

Why don't you point us at some pics and we'll help you identify them?
 
Last edited:
  • #5
The solar system is located in an environment which is relatively empty compared to the interstellar medium. It is called local bubble and was generated about a million years ago by some supernova events that blew out the interstellar medium. Bubbles like this are very usual in galaxies and form a fundamental part of the interstellar medium (galaxies look like swiss cheese). These bubbles contain also more dense clouds, especially near their walls. The sun is located within such a cloud called local fluff. Although the densities of such clouds are also small, they may have some effects on the heliosphere and the production of anomalous cosmic rays that enter the solar system.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
Dave has a good point -- sometimes concentrations of stars can look cloudy in broadband optical images (images in the frequency range our eyes can see). Most of what you see in such images is, in fact, from stars, but there are other types of images for which the majority of the light comes from the interstellar medium, such as H[itex]\alpha[/itex] and some infrared images.

A link to the picture or pictures you're referring to would be very helpful for answering your question in more detail.


jhe1984 said:
But I don't understand why the interstellar medium would "look" like clouds far away, but not close up? It seems like if they looked like anything it would be like a sort of illuminated asteroid belt.

What matters there is the column density. This is measured in particles per square centimeter and can be thought of as a rough measure of how much stuff you're looking "through" in the image. To understand how this applies to your illuminated asteroid analogy, imagine that instead of a belt, it were a large extended cloud. If the cloud were thick enough, then it might get to the point where our line of sight intersected an illuminated asteroid in almost any place on the cloud that we looked! At this point, the cloud of asteroids would start to look "fuzzy" or "cloudy".

The same idea applies to atoms. If the clouds are thick enough, they will appear fuzzy in our images.


Also, was that a typo or did you really say that the low end of the range of the interstellar medium (this is the stuff we see as 'inside' a galaxy, as opposed to empty space, right?) is one PARTICLE per cubic centimeter?

That's more like the typical density. The low end is more like one particle in every ten centimeters cubed.


Whoa. And that's reflective?

It can be, but in images of these clouds, you'd be seeing mostly direct emission.


One more question, do these "space clouds" appear (on whatever spectrum) moving relative to us, like Earth clouds relative to the ground?

The clouds do move relative to us, but their side-to-side motion is difficult to measure. It's much easier to measure their velocity toward or away from us because it produces a Doppler shift of their spectral lines.
 
  • #7
Okay both these images are bad (it's hard to not exceed 100 kb).

What I'm driving at is that in any given region (here, a red box) there is a hazy and noticeable color gradient. I am interpreting that as some sort of interstellar gas, and in the second image, that hazy gas surrounds the Sun (which is an aqua dot). If that gas - of different colors - were moving relative to the Sun in the Milky Way, how come we don't recognize changes (as in "yesterday was sure a dark brown cloudy spaceday" or "well next year is looking like light blue haze throughout the solar sytem", etc).

--- If you're not more confused after this "clarification", I am impressed.
 

Attachments

  • Galaxy I.jpg
    Galaxy I.jpg
    17.7 KB · Views: 594
  • Galaxy II.jpg
    Galaxy II.jpg
    3.4 KB · Views: 622
Last edited:
  • #8
jhe1984 said:
Okay both these images are bad (it's hard to not exceed 100 kb).

What I'm driving at is that in any given region (here, a red box) there is a hazy and noticeable color gradient. I am interpreting that as some sort of interstellar gas, and in the second image, that hazy gas surrounds the Sun (which is an aqua dot). If that gas - of different colors - were moving relative to the Sun in the Milky Way, how come we don't recognize changes (as in "yesterday was sure a dark brown cloudy spaceday" or "well next year is looking like light blue haze throughout the solar sytem", etc).

--- If you're not more confused after this "clarification", I am impressed.


The problem is you're not realizing the scale of these clouds. Think about fog, viewed by an ant, inside a cube of volume 1 cubic centimeter. If the density of the fog is the same as normal fog, the ant is unlikely to be able to notice it at all over those distances. Now take you looking at a cloud up in the sky. You see a thick hazy cloud. See the differece?
 
  • #9
Yes I think I understand the part about scope, but what I am still unclear about is this:
Is our solar system in the midst of a comparably cloudy portion of our galactic spiral arm or in a relatively empty region -- and does this change?

Edit: Never mind, I think Hellfire cleared up this last question. Also I found a good graphic from NASA about how our Sun's moving out of one of these cloud wisps...
 

Attachments

  • localcloud_frisch_big.gif
    localcloud_frisch_big.gif
    42.9 KB · Views: 645
Last edited:

What is the gas and debris in our solar system?

The gas and debris in our solar system are remnants of the formation of the planets and moons. They are made up of various elements such as hydrogen, helium, and dust particles.

How does the gas and debris impact the planets in our solar system?

The gas and debris can have a significant impact on the planets in our solar system. For example, they can contribute to the formation of new moons, alter the orbits of existing moons, and even influence the weather and climates of the planets.

Where is most of the gas and debris located in our solar system?

Most of the gas and debris in our solar system can be found in the outer regions, beyond the orbit of Neptune. This area is known as the Kuiper Belt and is home to many comets, asteroids, and other small bodies.

How do scientists study the gas and debris in our solar system?

Scientists use a variety of tools and techniques to study the gas and debris in our solar system. They may use telescopes to observe the objects, spacecraft to collect data, and computer simulations to model their behavior.

What are the potential dangers of gas and debris in our solar system?

While most of the gas and debris in our solar system is harmless, there are some potential dangers. Large objects such as asteroids and comets could potentially collide with planets, causing significant damage. Scientists are constantly monitoring these objects to assess any potential threats.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
2
Replies
62
Views
6K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
21
Views
852
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
40
Views
4K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
8
Views
7K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
1K
Back
Top