Question about precession in the case of frisbees

  • Thread starter Thundagere
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Precession
In summary, frisbees fly because of precession. Precession is the phenomenon where the angular momentum changes in the direction of a net torque, and in this case, the torque is from the ground.
  • #1
Thundagere
159
0
So, I was trying to figure out the physics of frisbees. When you throw a frisbee at the ground at an angle (such that the side to the left of you, assuming you are right handed, hits the ground first), then it will suddenly skip up and fly upwards (Youtube has some great videos of it, for anyone who hasn't seen this). Someone told me this was because of precession. How does this work?
Precession is the phenomenon where the angular momentum changes in the direction of a net torque, correct? In this case, we have an upward normal force, so a torque horizontal to the ground going away from the thrower on the edge of the frisbee. The angular momentum vector is, of course, through the axis of rotation. They're almost 90 degrees to each other, so how would precession work in this case to flip the frisbee up?
Thanks for any help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The frisbee is just bouncing off the ground, the same as any semi-elastic colliision. Precession also occurs, but almost all of the change in direction from the ground is due to bouncing.
 
  • #3
In this case, we have an upward normal force, so a torque horizontal to the ground going away from the thrower on the edge of the frisbee. The angular momentum vector is, of course, through the axis of rotation. They're almost 90 degrees to each other, so how would precession work in this case to flip the frisbee up?

Exactly.
From above the frisbee is rotating clockwise, so the rotation vector of the frisbee points down.

The normal attempts to twist the axis of rotation of the frisbee clockwise from your perspective.
So you have a torque vector from this normal pointing away from you.

From that you can deduce the direction of the resulting precession vector which will cause the frisbee axis of rotation to change direction and cause it to what looks like a skip and fly upwards.

Here is a site that explains how the three vectors are related:
http://www.motivate.maths.org/content/wonderful-world-gyroscopes/gyroscopic-effect
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
256bits, thanks for that website reference! One of the better explanations I've ever seen!
 
  • #5
256bits said:
From above the frisbee is rotating clockwise, so the rotation vector of the frisbee points down. The normal attempts to twist the axis of rotation of the frisbee clockwise from your perspective. So you have a torque vector from this normal pointing away from you.
So the result is a pitch upwards of the frisbee, causing it to climb, but there is an initial bounce, and I wasn't sure if you were asking about the bounce or the tendency to climb afterwards.

Also, for a cambered airfoil like a frisbee, there's a pitch down torque. This is somewhat compensated for by having the center of lift in front of the cetner of mass, but generally it's a pitch down torque, that results in a roll reaction (precession) during longer flights.

A flying ring, such as an aerobie, solves this problem and can be "tuned" so that it does not roll during long flights.

http://aerobie.com/about/ringscientificpaper.htm
 
Last edited by a moderator:

What is precession in the case of frisbees?

Precession in the case of frisbees refers to the gradual change in the orientation of a spinning frisbee as it flies through the air. This change in orientation is caused by the interaction between the frisbee's angular momentum and the aerodynamic forces acting on it.

Why does precession occur in frisbees?

Precession occurs in frisbees due to the conservation of angular momentum. As the frisbee spins, it creates a gyroscopic effect that causes it to resist changes in its orientation. However, as the frisbee moves through the air, it experiences aerodynamic forces that can cause it to tilt or wobble, resulting in precession.

What factors can affect precession in frisbees?

Several factors can affect precession in frisbees, including the speed and angle of the throw, the shape and weight distribution of the frisbee, and the air density and wind conditions. Additionally, the spin rate and stability of the frisbee can also impact the amount of precession.

How does precession impact the flight of a frisbee?

Precession can impact the flight of a frisbee by causing it to change direction or lose stability. This can result in the frisbee veering off course or even crashing to the ground. However, precession can also be used to control the flight of a frisbee, as skilled players can manipulate the spin and angle of the throw to create intentional precession.

Can precession be prevented in frisbees?

While precession cannot be completely prevented in frisbees, it can be minimized by using a well-balanced and stable frisbee and by throwing it with the correct angle and speed. Additionally, practicing proper throwing technique can help reduce the amount of precession and improve the overall flight of the frisbee.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
7
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
6K
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top