Is the phase diagram for an oscilliator always clockwise?

In summary: The summary of this conversation is: In summary, the direction of the phase diagram for an oscillator depends on how the axes are drawn. For a simple harmonic oscillator with x to the right and p upwards, the motion will be clockwise. This is because the restoring force of the oscillator causes the phase space points on the positive x-axis to move towards the negative p-axis, and then back to the starting point. However, this can be either clockwise or counterclockwise depending on how the axes are drawn.
  • #1
AlonsoMcLaren
90
2
Is the phase diagram for an oscilliator (all sorts of oscilliations) always clockwise? If it is so, why?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Clockwise or counterclockwise depends on how you draw your axes. You might choose p to the right and x up, or x to the right and p up. These two configurations would obviously change the orientation.

However, I think I know what you're referring to. Let's restrict our attention to a simple harmonic (F=-kx). Let's draw our phase space diagram with x to the right and p upwards.

Now let's say our system happens to be at a point on the x axis, in the positive region. (x is positive, p=0.) The force -kx would be to the left, meaning the particle's momentum would be decreasing at that point. So the path of the particle through phase space would be down from its initial point on the x axis, i.e. clockwise. (A similar argument applies for p=0 but x negative, yeilding again clockwise.) Similarly, if x=0 but p is positive, there is no force, but the particle is moving in the positive x direction, so this would also be clockwise.

You should see that because an oscillator is a restoring force, and since p is proportional to dx/dt, p always has the same sign as dx/dt but x always has the opposite sign as dp/dt. This translates to the fact that phase space points on the positive x-axis always evolve towards the negative p axis, then go to the negative x-axis, then to the positive p axis, and back to the starting point (given no damping/forcing/dissipation). This could be clockwise or counterclockwise depending on how you draw your axes.
 
  • #3
Short answer:

A positive momentum means that the position coordinate is increasing; a negative momentum means that position is decreasing.

It is conventional to draw oscillator diagrams with positive momentum in the +y direction, and positive position in the +x direction. For that way of drawing the axes, the motion has to be clockwise.
 

1. Is the phase diagram for an oscillator always clockwise?

No, the phase diagram for an oscillator can be clockwise or counterclockwise depending on the direction of the oscillation.

2. What does a clockwise phase diagram indicate?

A clockwise phase diagram indicates that the oscillator is moving in the same direction as the phase angle, meaning that the amplitude of the oscillation is increasing.

3. Is a clockwise phase diagram more common than a counterclockwise one?

No, the direction of the phase diagram depends on the specific system and its parameters, so there is no general trend for clockwise or counterclockwise phase diagrams to be more common.

4. Can the direction of the phase diagram change over time?

Yes, the direction of the phase diagram can change if the parameters of the system change, causing the behavior of the oscillator to change.

5. How does the phase diagram for an oscillator relate to its stability?

The shape and direction of the phase diagram can provide information about the stability of the oscillator. A stable oscillator will have a closed loop in the phase diagram, while an unstable oscillator will have an open loop. The direction of the phase diagram can also indicate the rate of change in the amplitude of the oscillation, with a clockwise direction indicating increasing amplitude and a counterclockwise direction indicating decreasing amplitude.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
828
Replies
23
Views
963
Replies
5
Views
892
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
250
  • Classical Physics
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
2
Views
638
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
15
Views
446
Replies
6
Views
826
Replies
9
Views
834
  • Classical Physics
Replies
20
Views
1K
Back
Top