Number density/average distance relationship question

In summary, the conversation revolves around a question about number density and average distance in the context of a galactic disk. The approach to solving this question can either be 3-dimensional or 2-dimensional, depending on the population density of objects. The question asks at what mean distance does the transition from a 2D to 3D approach occur, and involves calculus. The use of area to compute the average number density is discussed, and it is mentioned that volume is always the more accurate approach. The question is clarified to be about when the 2D approach fails to provide accurate results, and suggests constructing a 3D model of the system to solve the problem.
  • #1
QuantumX
31
0
I am having trouble with this number density astrophysics question. Any help is greatly appreciated:

Consider a galactic disk with radius much larger than its thickness. Let R be the radius and the thickness be 2H where H is the ‘scale height’ of the disk. For a population of objects with large n3, the mean distance is small and a 3-dimensional approach can be taken. For a sparse population with large mean distance, a 2-dimensional (area) approach is appropriate where n2 is the integral of n3 through the disk vertically. At what mean distance does the transition from a 2D to 3D approach occur?

This question has to do with the relationship between number density and average distance, which is (I think) average distance = 1/cube root(density) for 3D space and 1/square root(density) for 2D space.

It involves calculus which I'm not too comfortable with and I'm not sure where to start... Please help!
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
If this is a homework problem, then you need to post it in the homework forum. An integral is just the sum of a variable quantity over the path or distance (or volume, area, set, space, ...). The average over any of these things is just this sum divided by the whole (length, area, path, distance, set, space...). In other words the average is proportional to the integral, only differing by the divisor (which often is constant).
I find the question a bit confusing:"At what mean distance does the transition from a 2D to 3D approach occur?"
""approach"" ? approach TO WHAT?? Based on your comments I guess it is using area to compute the average(?) number density compared to using volume. Well, volume (assuming we are talking about 3D space (where we live) and assuming that time evolution is not involved) is always correct, area will only be an approximation. Its generally used because it simplifies the calculations (although sometimes it is used because one or more of the assumptions in the 3D calculation are inappropriate when the 3 dimensions aren't roughly equal). Given this, the question becomes: "When does the 2D approach fail to provide accurate n (number density) ?" You need to construct a 3D model of the system. What is appropriate? A disc? A flying saucer type shape (ellipsoidal)? A disc is a cylinder, right?
 

1. What is number density and how is it calculated?

Number density is a measure of the number of particles or objects per unit volume. It is calculated by dividing the total number of particles by the volume of the space they occupy.

2. How does number density affect the average distance between particles?

The higher the number density, the closer the particles are to each other, resulting in a smaller average distance between them. Conversely, a lower number density means the particles are more spread out and the average distance between them is larger.

3. What factors can affect the number density of a substance?

The number density of a substance can be affected by factors such as temperature, pressure, and the size and shape of the particles. Changes in these factors can lead to changes in the volume or number of particles, thus impacting the number density.

4. How is the number density/average distance relationship useful in scientific research?

This relationship is useful in various scientific fields, such as chemistry and astrophysics, as it allows researchers to understand the distribution and behavior of particles in a given space. It can also help in predicting the properties and interactions of substances.

5. Is there a direct relationship between number density and average distance?

No, there is an inverse relationship between number density and average distance. As the number density increases, the average distance between particles decreases, and vice versa. This relationship is known as the inverse proportionality.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
2
Replies
49
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • General Math
Replies
3
Views
875
Replies
1
Views
787
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
744
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
0
Views
975
  • Cosmology
Replies
24
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top