How to calculate spinning disc torque which resists tilting of the disc's axis?

In summary: Hello,In summary, a spinning disc has angular momentum and responds paradoxically to attempts to tilt it, creating a transverse torque. This effect is used in devices such as a Levitron to stabilize a magnetic disc from flipping upside down. The stability is not due to spin, but rather the property of a spinning gyroscope wheel to resist immediate flip-over. However, this effect is subject to decay as friction decreases the spin rate of the wheel.
  • #1
kdbachovchin
3
0
Hello,

From what I've read, I understand that a spinning disc has a torque which resists the tilting of the disc's axis. From what I understand, the higher the angular velocity of the disc is, the more the disc will resist tilting. Can anyone tell me how to calculate this torque? If there is not a simple explanation, could you give me a reference to a book or a paper that describes this?

Thanks,
Kevin
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
No, a spinning disc has angular momentum (ML[itex]^{2}[/itex]/T). A torque is a rate of change of angular momentum (ML[itex]^{2}[/itex]/T[itex]^{2}[/itex]). Like the difference between speed and acceleration.
It's not that the disc resists tilting. This is a common misunderstanding of how gyroscopes work. Rather, the disc responds paradoxically to an attempt to tilt it. Imagine trying to push a trolley forwards, but it responds by moving sideways. (As indeed it might if the castors are stuck at an angle.) Your natural inclination would be to resist the sideways movement and persist in pushing forwards. Now you would feel resistance, but it's your own resistance to the sideways movement being relayed back to you.
The same happens with a gyroscope. Suppose it's spinning on a vertical axis and you try to tip the top of it away from you. Instead, it will tend to tip to the left or right, depending on which way it's spinning. If mounted in a gimbal, so that it is free to tip left or right, you will not feel any resistance, but if holding it in your hand you will tend to resist the paradoxical response, so you do feel resistance.
If the disc has moment of inertia M and spins at rate w then its angular momentum is Mw. If you rotate it at right angles to its spin axis at speed u (an angular velocity) then to inhibit the paradoxical response you will need to supply a transverse torque Mwu.
(The M.I. of a uniform disc is its mass * radius squared / 2.)
 
  • #3
Hi haruspex,

Thanks for your reply. I understand what you are saying, but I'm not quite sure how to apply this for my example. Maybe I should clarify my question.

I am considering levitating one magnetic disk above another magnetic disk. The two disks repel each other, so that the downward gravitational force on the upper magnet cancels the upward levitation force. If the upper disk is not spinning, then a torque will act to tilt the upper magnet so that it tilts 180 degrees (and now the upper magnet will be attracted to the lower magnet, which obviously destroys the levitation). Electromagnetics is my specific area of study, so I can compute this torque easily. I have plotted the torque as a function of tilt angle and confirmed that the torque acts to flip the upper magnet upside down. (In order words the stable equilibrium occurs when the upper magnet tilts 180 degrees.)

However, from what I've read, if the upper disk is spinning (as in Levitron devices), then this spin stabilizes the device from flipping upside down. However I don't have a mechanical engineering background, so I'm not sure how to model this mathematically. Do you have any thoughts for how I can combine the gyroscopic effects with the magnetic torque I know how to calculate and show that when spinning the upper disk won't flip upside down?

Thanks again,
Kevin
 
  • #4
Can you define the magnetisation for me? Is each disc N on one face and S on the other (and you place them with two similar poles facing)?
 
  • #5
Yes, that's correct. The lower disc has magnetization in the positive vertical direction (North pole on the top surface and South pole on the bottom surface) while the upper disc has magnetization in the negative vertical direction (North pole on the bottom surface and South pole on the top surface).
 
  • #6
I think the calculation would involve perturbation analysis. After all, that's why it's not stable when not spinning. I'll have a think about it, but it looks nasty.
Meanwhile
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #7
Well, I've thought about it a bit and more and realize I don't understand why it would flip over without spin. Why wouldn't it just slide off to one side, like a plate off a smooth dome?
Maybe the lower disc is much wider, so the upper disc would have time to flip over before escaping to the side of the lower? That being the case, spinning it might inhibit the flip but still allow the slide.
 
  • #8
kdbachovchin said:
[...] However, from what I've read, if the upper disk is spinning (as in Levitron devices), then this spin stabilizes the device from flipping upside down.

Hi Kevin,

As Haruspex pointed out already, it's not so much a stabilisation.

The property of a spinning gyroscope wheel of not yielding immediately to flip-over is subject to decay. As friction decreases the wheel's spin rate any wobble gets bigger and bigger.

As Haruspex writes: the response to keeling of the spin axis in one direction is acceleration in a direction perpendicular to it. Because of that right angles effect the dynamics of gyroscopic precession is by nature cyclic.

I've written before about gyroscopic effects, and for that posting I uploaded two images, so I refer to that post from november 2010 about gyroscope physics
 

1. How do you calculate the torque on a spinning disc?

The torque on a spinning disc can be calculated by multiplying the force applied to the disc by the distance from the point of application to the axis of rotation.

2. What is the formula for calculating torque on a spinning disc?

The formula for calculating torque on a spinning disc is: Torque = Force x Distance from point of application to axis of rotation.

3. Can you provide an example of calculating torque on a spinning disc?

Sure, for example, if a force of 10 N is applied to a disc at a distance of 0.5 meters from the axis of rotation, the torque would be 10 N x 0.5 m = 5 Nm.

4. How does the angle of the disc's axis affect the torque?

The angle of the disc's axis does not directly affect the torque. However, if the disc is tilted, the distance from the point of application to the axis of rotation will change, which will affect the torque.

5. What factors can affect the resistance to tilting of a spinning disc's axis?

The resistance to tilting of a spinning disc's axis can be affected by the mass and shape of the disc, the speed of rotation, the location and magnitude of any external forces, and the material and surface of the disc.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
2
Replies
43
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
736
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Back
Top