What is the force applied by the handbrake to stop the car?

  • Thread starter baztack
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses a question related to Newton's laws of motion. The question involves a car being driven at a constant velocity of 30.0 m/s and then experiencing a sudden brake failure. The car then coasts for 25.0 seconds before the driver applies the handbrake to bring the car to a stop in 3.0 seconds. The conversation involves finding the average acceleration and average force of air against the car, as well as the force applied by the handbrake. The conversation also includes hints and suggestions for solving the problem, such as considering the forces of friction and using the equations for motion with uniform acceleration.
  • #1
baztack
5
0
Hi I am getting into the section of Newtons laws and came across this question which I found difficult.

The question reads:

Roberta drives her 1452kg car along a straight, level road at a constant velocity of 30.0 m/s {E}. Her brakes suddenly give out. She puts the car in heutral and let's it coast for 25.0s. The air drag decelerates the car to a velocity of 25.0m/s[E].(Assume a frictionless surface)

A) Draw a freebody diafra, of the car before the breaks give out and while coasting... I think I got this one right...

B)Determine the avergae accleration furing this interval...
My answer: G: deltaTime - 25.0s, deltaVelocity - 30.0m/s
R: acceleration
A: a=deltav/deltat
s: a = 30/25 =1.2m/s
P: avg acceleration is 1.2m/s

C) Determine the average force of air against the car.
G: Mcar=1452kg, accel=1.2m/s
R: Fair
A: Fair=(m)(accel)
S: Fair=1452kg x 1.2m/s
=1742.4N
P: Avg force of air against the car is 174x10 N.
Im assuming up to this point that my calculations are correct... if you see a problem please hint and let me know...

This is where I am running into trouble...
D) After coasting for 25.0s, Roberta pulls her handbrake to slow the car to a stop. If it takes 3.0s to stop the car, what is the force applied by the handbrake? Assume that the force exerted by the air remains constand and is equal to the force determined in part c.

I have my givens mapped out G: m=1452kg, V1=30.0m/s, V2=25.0m/s, T1=25.0s, T2=28.0s, Fair=1742.4N
R: Fapp?

For the rest of the question I was trying to firgure out exactly how to go about finding a solution to this problem. I know that F=m(accel) so should I use an acceleration equation to find the accleration then plug it into the F=M(accel) to get the force of the applied handbrake?

Sorry I've just been stuck on this question now for hours and any help would be greatly appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
baztack said:
Roberta drives her 1452kg car along a straight, level road at a constant velocity of 30.0 m/s {E}. Her brakes suddenly give out. She puts the car in heutral and let's it coast for 25.0s. The air drag decelerates the car to a velocity of 25.0m/s[E].

My answer: ... deltaVelocity - 30.0m/s
Recheck that !
 
  • #3
After, you have recheck your answer, and refind the force of air. Here's some hints:
There are two force that slows the car down : air force and (hand brake) friction force.
You have already known the air force. You can also know the acceleration of the car (you know [itex]\Delta t = 3.0 s[/itex] and [itex]\Delta v = - 25.0 m/s[/itex]).
You also know the mass of the car. Can you work out the force of friction?
Viet Dao,
EDIT:
Just one more thing : acceleration is [itex]m / s ^ {2}[/itex] not [itex]m / s[/itex] like you type in your post.
 
  • #4
baztack said:
P: avg acceleration is 1.2m/s

I thing to remember here is that the car in your problem is slowing down, thus the acceleration cannot be positive. Little things like these help you quickly spot simple mistakes.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
The equations you are using are for motion with uniform acceleration only. When the handbrake is applied the force and hence the acceleration is changed, so we have to solve the second part seperately
Vin = 25 m/s ; Vfin = 0; F = -(1742.4 + Fb) and t = 3 s
 
  • #6
Hi thanks for the input... I realize acceleration is m/s squared but I am not sure how to type the squared sign on the computer...

Also in the original question is says to asssume a frictionless surface so I don't think it is necessary to find the force of friction...

VietDao29 said:
After, you have recheck your answer, and refind the force of air. Here's some hints:
There are two force that slows the car down : air force and (hand brake) friction force.
You have already known the air force. You can also know the acceleration of the car (you know [itex]\Delta t = 3.0 s[/itex] and [itex]\Delta v = - 25.0 m/s[/itex]).
You also know the mass of the car. Can you work out the force of friction?
Viet Dao,
EDIT:
Just one more thing : acceleration is [itex]m / s ^ {2}[/itex] not [itex]m / s[/itex] like you type in your post.
 
  • #7
[itex]m / s ^ {2}[/itex]
 
  • #8
baztack said:
Also in the original question is says to asssume a frictionless surface so I don't think it is necessary to find the force of friction...

The hand brake uses friction to slow the car, that is what he is referring to.
 
  • #9
zwtipp05 said:
The hand brake uses friction to slow the car, that is what he is referring to.

Oh okay thank you for clearing that up... I will be finishing my attemp at these questions and a bunch more later tonight/tomorrow morning and will post my conclusions.. thank you all for your help thus far.
 
  • #10
Okay I tried to solve part b,c and d again...

b) G:DeltaV= -25m/s, DeltaT=25.0s
R: Accel
A: Accel= deltaV/deltaT
s: Accel= -25m/s / 25s = -1.0m/s^2
p: The avg acceleration of the car is -1.0m/s^2 during this interval.

c) G:Accel=-1.0m/s^2, Mcar=1542kg
R: Fair
A: Fair=(m)(accel)
s: Fair=(1542kg)(-1.0m/s^2) = 1542N
p: The average force of the air is -1542N.

d) G: F= -(-1542kg + Fb), Accel=-1.0m/s^2, Mcar=1542kg
R: Fb
A: F=(m)(accel)
S: 1542 - Fb = (1542Kg) (-1.0m/s^2)
-Fb= -1542N - 1542N
-Fb= -3084N
Fb= 3084N
P: The force applied by the handbrake is 3084N


Any comments about these conclusions would be appreciated... I have a strange feeling I am still off in a couple of them.
 
  • #11
baztack said:
Okay I tried to solve part b,c and d again...

b) G:DeltaV= -25m/s, DeltaT=25.0s
R: Accel
A: Accel= deltaV/deltaT
s: Accel= -25m/s / 25s = -1.0m/s^2
p: The avg acceleration of the car is -1.0m/s^2 during this interval.

c) G:Accel=-1.0m/s^2, Mcar=1542kg
R: Fair
A: Fair=(m)(accel)
s: Fair=(1542kg)(-1.0m/s^2) = 1542N
p: The average force of the air is -1542N.

d) G: F= -(-1542kg + Fb), Accel=-1.0m/s^2, Mcar=1542kg
R: Fb
A: F=(m)(accel)
S: 1542 - Fb = (1542Kg) (-1.0m/s^2)
-Fb= -1542N - 1542N
-Fb= -3084N
Fb= 3084N
P: The force applied by the handbrake is 3084N


Any comments about these conclusions would be appreciated... I have a strange feeling I am still off in a couple of them.


Ok, for part b, you are looking for the average acceleration during coasting.
She goes from 30 m/s to 25 m/s over a time of 25 s. Therefore we get 5 m/s for change in velocity and 25 s for change in time. So a = 5/25 = .2 m/(s^2)

For part c you have the right method, but your answer was wrong due to your error in part b. F=ma F= 1542 kg * .2 m/(s^2)
F = 308.4 N

For part d, you should approach like parts b and c combined.
The car goes from 25 m/s to 0 m/s in 3 s. So change in velocity is 25 m/s and change in time is 3 s.
This gives an acceleration of 25/3 or a=8.33 m/(s^2)

Now use the method in part c.
F= ma
308.4 + Force of the Hand Brake = 1542 kg * 8.33 m/(s^2)

We get 308.4 + Force of the Hand Brake = 12850
So Force of the Hand Brake = 12541.6 N

You have to be very careful and make sure you only looking at what the changes are in the time frame indicated.

BTW, I'm curious, What does RASP stand for?
 
  • #12
Thank you for your reply... rasp is actually Grasp and its a method which was taught to me to somewhat organize your solutions.

G- givens
R- what's Required
A- The Analysis ie) eqns that will be used
S- The Solution where all the work is done
P- the paraphrase to answer the original question in words.
 

1. What is the definition of "trouble on a question" in science?

"Trouble on a question" in science refers to a situation where a hypothesis or research question cannot be fully answered or supported by the available evidence. It may also refer to conflicting or inconclusive results that make it difficult to draw conclusions.

2. What are some common causes of trouble on a question in scientific research?

There are several potential causes of trouble on a question in scientific research, including insufficient or biased data, flawed experimental design, and inadequate sample size. Other factors may include unforeseen confounding variables or limitations in technology or methodology.

3. How can scientists address trouble on a question in their research?

To address trouble on a question, scientists may need to revise their research methods, gather additional data, or collaborate with other researchers. It may also be necessary to re-evaluate the original hypothesis or research question and consider alternative explanations or interpretations of the data.

4. Is trouble on a question always a negative thing in scientific research?

No, trouble on a question can also be a valuable opportunity for scientific discovery and advancement. It challenges scientists to think critically and creatively, and may lead to new insights or unexpected discoveries. It also encourages further research and collaboration within the scientific community.

5. How can scientists prevent or minimize trouble on a question in their research?

While some degree of trouble on a question is inevitable in scientific research, scientists can take steps to minimize its impact. This includes carefully planning and designing experiments, conducting thorough literature reviews, and being aware of potential biases and limitations in their methods. Open communication and collaboration with other researchers can also help to mitigate and address any potential trouble on a question.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
5K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Back
Top