| New Reply |
Big bang versus black hole |
Share Thread |
| Feb8-13, 06:33 PM | #1 |
|
|
Big bang versus black hole
In this FAQ at the Baez website, the big bang singularity is contrasted with a black and white hole as a possible beginning of our universe.
Is the Big Bang a black hole? http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physic.../universe.html [I'm not interested in answering the title question,which is NO, but rather exploring the differences.] A few major differences are outlined: Three questions: what about the temperature difference between the two....less than 3 degrees K for many black holes and 1028 degrees K for the big bang....Does this manifest in the differences or is temperature relatively unimportant? Also, Is SPACE hardly curved at the big bang, just time, while for a black hole both space and time are severely curved?? If so, does the extreme curvature of time relate to the temperature difference? to the initial expansion/repulsion? Do we have any quantum insights yet that support, contradict or offer other insights? edit: from another thread, I saved this partial insight: Pervect: "Because the stress-energy tensor for expanding matter is different from the stress-energy tensor of non-expanding matter, you can have compact, dense, expanding objects that are not black holes." ok. |
| Feb8-13, 06:49 PM | #2 |
|
|
I posted this elsewhere:
http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/encyclopedia/Spacetime/ I checked Lee Smolin's THREE ROADS TO QUANTUM GRAVITY [year 2000] and he discusses LQG in terms of evolving [Penrose] spin networks in some detail, and has done research himself, but says nothing about the geometry relative to BH and BB... |
| New Reply |
Similar discussions for: Big bang versus black hole
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | ||
| Why didn't the big bang just become a black hole? | Cosmology | 51 | ||
| Big Bang From Black Hole. Each Black Hole creates a New galaxy? | Cosmology | 21 | ||
| Black hole versus 2nd law of thermaldynamics | Classical Physics | 8 | ||
| Was big bang a Black Hole Ex... | Cosmology | 1 | ||
| Big bang black hole | General Astronomy | 4 | ||