If speed of light is constant, how does prismatic color shift occur?

In summary: I see. So in other words, if I were to take a reading of a star's speed through air at night, the reading would be inaccurate because the star would be traveling through a medium with differing refractive indices (e.g. water vs air), and the refraction would affect the star's velocity?I see. So in other words, if I were to take a reading of a star's speed through air at night, the reading would be inaccurate because the star would be traveling through a medium with differing refractive indices (e.g. water vs air), and the refraction would affect the star's velocity?
  • #1
AJHank
4
0
If differing wavelengths explain color variations, would not the longer "zig-zags" of the separate colors for the bluer spectrum portions of visible light suggest that they have traveled longer to get to a discrete point from that of their origin? - Assuming that the component colors of visible light began at the point at the same time - and does frequency play a part in this? And what about the observable bend and shift when a straight object is observed entering water from the air?
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
When traveling through a medium such as glass, the effective speed of light is slower (compared to its speed in vacuum) and also depends on the frequency. Generally, blue light (higher frequency) travels slower than red light (lower frequency) through a transparent medium such as a glass prism. (This dependence of speed on color is called chromatic dispersion.)

And when light crosses the interface between two media (like between air and glass or air and water), the direction changes according to Snell's law of refraction. The amount of refraction (bending) depends on the relative speed of the light in the two media. Thus, going back to the prism, blue light gets bent more than red, allowing the different colors to be spread out in a spectral pattern.
 
  • #3
Is light from distant sources then always out of phase?

Thank You for your reply. And you centered me on what was troubling me: if the varying portions of the spectrum are traveling at different speeds, then what exactly are we observing from very distant objects when the entire (or a great portion thereof) spectrum seems to arrive at our point of of observation. Why do stars, for example, appear to be white light to our eyes??
 
  • #4
AJHank said:
Thank You for your reply. And you centered me on what was troubling me: if the varying portions of the spectrum are traveling at different speeds, then what exactly are we observing from very distant objects when the entire (or a great portion thereof) spectrum seems to arrive at our point of of observation. Why do stars, for example, appear to be white light to our eyes??

Your eyes are not a very good measuring device.

Zz.
 
  • #5
Just to be sure you understood the answer; the varying portions of the spectrum travel at different speeds only happens in a non-vacuum medium. Thus this doesn’t apply to starlight traveling in a vacuum.

Also when we look closely (and take measurements) we see that starlight is not ‘white’. The futher it came from the more it shifts to the red (Hubble). And if it came from a star surface effected by a very very heavy star with significant time distortion at that surface it is shifted even more red (Einstein GR).

Finally on that “prism” if the surfaces happen to be parallel (flat glass) and the light hits at an angle, the blue light travels a shorter distance in the glass so it comes out sooner and has extra time at full speed to ‘catch-up’ to the rest. Thus no net bend or color change for flat glass.
 
  • #6
RandallB said:
Just to be sure you understood the answer; the varying portions of the spectrum travel at different speeds only happens in a non-vacuum medium. Thus this doesn’t apply to starlight traveling in a vacuum.
Also when we look closely (and take measurements) we see that starlight is not ‘white’. The futher it came from the more it shifts to the red (Hubble). And if it came from a star surface effected by a very very heavy star with significant time distortion at that surface it is shifted even more red (Einstein GR).
Finally on that “prism” if the surfaces happen to be parallel (flat glass) and the light hits at an angle, the blue light travels a shorter distance in the glass so it comes out sooner and has extra time at full speed to ‘catch-up’ to the rest. Thus no net bend or color change for flat glass.

Additionally the colour of the star is determined by the surface temperature and is pretty well modeled as a black body. Cooler stars are towards the red end of the spectrum and hotter stars the blue.
 
  • #7
Wouldn't refraction epitomise the speed of light entering different mediums and affect its overall speed reading?
 
  • #8
DM said:
Wouldn't refraction epitomise the speed of light entering different mediums and affect its overall speed reading?

In a normal dispersive medium, the different index of refraction would affect its GROUP VELOCITY.

Zz.
 

1. How does the speed of light affect the color of prisms?

The speed of light is constant in a vacuum, meaning it travels at the same speed regardless of the wavelength or color. However, when light passes through a medium such as a prism, its speed can be altered causing it to bend and separate into different colors.

2. What causes the color shift in prisms?

The color shift in prisms is caused by a phenomenon known as refraction. This is when light travels through a medium, such as glass, and changes direction due to a change in speed. The different colors of light have different wavelengths, causing them to bend at different angles and create the rainbow effect seen in prisms.

3. Is the speed of light different for each color?

No, the speed of light remains constant for all colors. However, the speed of light may vary depending on the medium it is passing through, such as air, water, or glass. This can cause the different colors to bend and separate at different angles, resulting in the color shift in prisms.

4. Can prismatic color shift occur with other types of light?

Yes, prismatic color shift can occur with any type of light, including sunlight, artificial light, and even laser light. As long as the light passes through a medium, it can be refracted and separated into its different colors.

5. Can the speed of light be altered to change the color shift in prisms?

The speed of light cannot be altered, as it is a fundamental constant in the universe. However, the angle and shape of the prism can be changed to affect the refraction of light and potentially alter the color shift seen. This is the basis for how optical instruments, such as spectrometers, work to analyze the different wavelengths of light.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
755
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
30
Views
2K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
14
Views
970
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
45
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • Optics
Replies
13
Views
1K
Back
Top