Dividing cancels out a solution?


by ainster31
Tags: cancels, dividing, solution
ainster31
ainster31 is offline
#1
Dec4-13, 10:01 AM
P: 154
Context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQM-8Oj4Ecg

In the video, he divides out a variable as below:
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\r=2sin\theta$$
When you do a division like this, aren't you dividing out a variable?

What happens if you take the square root of both sides like below?
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\|r|=\sqrt{2rsin\theta}$$
Would that be more correct?
Phys.Org News Partner Mathematics news on Phys.org
Math modeling handbook now available
Hyperbolic homogeneous polynomials, oh my!
Researchers help Boston Marathon organizers plan for 2014 race
HallsofIvy
HallsofIvy is offline
#2
Dec4-13, 10:06 AM
Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 38,902
Yes, he is. I particular, he has "lost" the r= 0 for all [itex]\theta[/itex] solution.

I'm not sure what you mean by "more correct" for [itex]|r|= \sqrt{2r sin(\theta)}[/itex]. It is not at all a "solution" because you have not "solved for r".
Mark44
Mark44 is offline
#3
Dec4-13, 10:07 AM
Mentor
P: 21,071
Quote Quote by ainster31 View Post
Context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQM-8Oj4Ecg

In the video, he divides out a variable as below:
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\r=2sin\theta$$
When you do a division like this, aren't you dividing out a variable?
Well, of course. The more important point is that you are potentially losing a solution of the equation; namely, r = 0. In this case, it doesn't matter because the equation r = 2sin(θ) still has r = 0 when θ = 0 + k##\pi##.
Quote Quote by ainster31 View Post

What happens if you take the square root of both sides like below?
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\|r|=\sqrt{2rsin\theta}$$
Would that be more correct?
No, and besides, what's the point? You haven't solved for r since it still appears on both sides of the equation.

ainster31
ainster31 is offline
#4
Dec4-13, 10:10 AM
P: 154

Dividing cancels out a solution?


How did you know he cancels out the ##r=0## solution?
Nugatory
Nugatory is offline
#5
Dec4-13, 02:08 PM
Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 2,972
Quote Quote by ainster31 View Post
How did you know he cancels out the ##r=0## solution?
Because that's the solution that always disappears when you divide by a variable. The only root of ##rA(...) = rB(...)## with ##A\neq{B}## is ##r=0##, and that's the one that we're losing when we divide both sides by ##r## to turn the equation into ##A(...) = B(...)##.
Office_Shredder
Office_Shredder is offline
#6
Dec4-13, 02:54 PM
Mentor
P: 4,499
Quote Quote by ainster31 View Post
How did you know he cancels out the ##r=0## solution?
Any time you divide both sides of an expression by something, you should check to see whether that thing can be zero. If it can be, then you have lost solutions corresponding to when that equals zero. For example, if someone asks you to solve:

(x-1)(x-2) = (x-1)(2x-1)

The first thing we do is divide both sides by x-1
(x-2) = (2x-1)

Now we solve for x
x = -1

OK, but we divided both sides by x-1, and we have to be worried about when that is equal to zero. x-1= 0 when x=1, so I should go back to the original equation and check that x=1 is a solution, which it is easily seen to be.
Jarfi
Jarfi is offline
#7
Dec4-13, 05:28 PM
P: 264
Quote Quote by ainster31 View Post
Context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQM-8Oj4Ecg

In the video, he divides out a variable as below:
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\r=2sin\theta$$
When you do a division like this, aren't you dividing out a variable?

What happens if you take the square root of both sides like below?
$$r^2=2rsin\theta\\|r|=\sqrt{2rsin\theta}$$
Would that be more correct?
Simply do:

r^2=2rsin\theta\ <-> r(r-2sin\theta\)=0 <-> r = 0 or r = 2sin\theta\


problem solved !

(sorry I dont know how to do the maths letters here )


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Point where magnetic field cancels between two current carrying wires. Introductory Physics Homework 7
NASA cancels Laser Interferometer Space Antenna Astrophysics 5
Earthward Upper Stratospheric IR Radiation Cancels Most Greenhouse Gas Effect Earth 9
Clinton cancels commencement speech General Discussion 24
when gravity cancels out General Physics 42