New Reply

Photons Are 'Wave-like' in What Way Exactly?

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Feb18-13, 11:43 AM   #18
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member

Photons Are 'Wave-like' in What Way Exactly?


Quote by sanman View Post
So are we saying that photons oscillate in all of their properties? Is there no property of the photon which does not oscillate, but instead stays constant?
Spin, charge, and a few others I'm sure.

I just feel a little frustrated with the "LIKE" part of "wave-like"
That's because a photon also behaves in a "particle-like" manner. If it was only a wave then you wouldn't have "wave-like" being thrown around. Actually if it was only a wave you wouldn't even have a photon at all since it's the quantized interaction of the EM wave.

When we say 2+2=4 then we know exactly what that means.
But if we say that "2 plus 2 is 4-like" then what the hell does that even mean??
It's important to understand that the theory that describes photons NEVER says "wave-like". It explains it in perfectly clear mathematical language that is subsequently garbled beyond all recognition when you try to explain it in everyday language. This isn't a problem just with photons, but with many things in science that are very clear when you are working with the theory itself but are almost impossible to adequately describe when you have to reword it for someone who isn't familiar with the theory.
 
Feb18-13, 12:28 PM   #19
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
sanman posts:
What most obvious physical property would I look at first to immediately identify that the photon is in fact wave-like?
What you really mean is that a photon " is both wave like and particle like'. The most obvious physical property is what you choose to detect it.....Different circumstances tease out one property or the other.

You simply have to read accepted experimental evidence which reveals current understanding.
None is better than the double slit experiment [wave particle duality] and the photoelectric [particle] effect explanations. Wikipedia has the necessary insights regarding each.

These are not necessarily intuitive and arrived at via some suddenly "EUREKA" moment...but are observational, empirical results. It's the way stuff works and that's why quantum mechanic models are the way they are...to mimic what is observed experimentally.
 
New Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Photons Are 'Wave-like' in What Way Exactly?
Thread Forum Replies
Photons, what makes them a act like a wave? Quantum Physics 2
How Many Photons in a Light Wave Quantum Physics 3
Photons wave-like behaviour Quantum Physics 8
photons in the stationary wave? Special & General Relativity 5
Long wave photons General Physics 3