New Reply

Internal (gauge) symmetries and spacetime symmetries

 
Share Thread
Jul25-12, 01:25 AM   #52
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor

Internal (gauge) symmetries and spacetime symmetries


Quote by TrickyDicky View Post
Hey, didn't know you were so radical.
depends on the enemy ...
Jul25-12, 01:52 PM   #53
 
Quote by tom.stoer View Post
I doubt that this will work and therefore I expect that many of these no-go theorems will cease to exist when identifying a fundamental theory of quantum gravity.
Now I have a question bearing some level of radicalness :)

Is there an empirical reason to be led to believe that gravity is (or should be) quantized? Or is it principally a consistency in frameworks that one assumes should be accommodated?
Jul25-12, 01:59 PM   #54
 
Quote by PhilDSP View Post
Now I have a question bearing some level of radicalness :)

Is there an empirical reason to be led to believe that gravity is (or should be) quantized? Or is it principally a consistency in frameworks that one assumes should be accommodated?
I remember having read somewhere a physicist that claimed that gravity was already "quantized" in GR. I will try to find the reference because I can't remember what kind of arguments he used or what he meant.
Jul25-12, 03:31 PM   #55
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Quote by PhilDSP View Post
Is there an empirical reason to be led to believe that gravity is (or should be) quantized? Or is it principally a consistency in frameworks that one assumes should be accommodated?
There is no direct experimental evidence for quantum gravity, so I would say that the indications are mostly due to theoretical and consistency reasons; but there are a lot ...
New Reply

Similar Threads for: Internal (gauge) symmetries and spacetime symmetries
Thread Forum Replies
GUT Proposed Gauge Symmetries Beyond the Standard Model 9
Gauge symmetries of a theory Advanced Physics Homework 0
Actions, symmetries, and gauge theories General Physics 3
Must gauge symmetries be factored out? General Physics 0
Must gauge symmetries be factored out? General Physics 0