# Proton, electron charge equal

by kye
Tags: charge, electron, equal, proton
 Share this thread:
 P: 168 Why (or what mathematical reason) is the charge of the electron being -1.60217733 x 10-19 C equal to the charge of the proton but opposite in size? Proton are composed of quarks and electrons don't have anything to do with quarks.
 P: 935 That's what we see in nature,experimentally, and there is no explanation for it yet,at least non that is proved!
 Mentor P: 12,010 There is no underlying reason why fundamental properties exist. They just do. Perhaps our understanding will change in the future.
 P: 168 Proton, electron charge equal There are 3 quarks in a proton. What is the value of each quark such that the composite proton has the value 1.60217733 x 10-19 C? Or how does each of the 3 quarks contribute to this value?
P: 935
 Quote by kye There are 3 quarks in a proton. What is the value of each quark such that the composite proton has the value 1.60217733 x 10-19 C? Or how does each of the 3 quarks contribute to this value?
A proton has 2 up quarks and 1 down quark.Up quarks have electric charge equal to $+\frac{2}{3}e$ and down quarks have electric charge equal to $-\frac{1}{3}e$ where e is the charge on a proton.
P: 168
 Quote by Shyan A proton has 2 up quarks and 1 down quark.Up quarks have electric charge equal to $+\frac{2}{3}e$ and down quarks have electric charge equal to $-\frac{1}{3}e$ where e is the charge on a proton.
It sounds like an up quark is composed of 2/3 of electron and down quark is composed of 1/3 of electron. Won't it sounds like an electron is composed of 3 units. I know we treat it as a point object. But the Landau problem says an electron can't be a point because its electric charge at infinite center would repel each other. So there is still hope an electron can be even composed of smaller objects bound together to form an electron?
Mentor
P: 12,010
 Quote by kye It sounds like an up quark is composed of 2/3 of electron and down quark is composed of 1/3 of electron. Won't it sounds like an electron is composed of 3 units. I know we treat it as a point object. But the Landau problem says an electron can't be a point because its electric charge at infinite center would repel each other. So there is still hope an electron can be even composed of smaller objects bound together to form an electron?
Not much hope, no. Electrons are thought to be fundamental particles.
 Thanks P: 1,948 There is no explanation for that apparent "coincidence" between the charges of the quarks and the electron within the Standard model (except for the highly technical requirement of triangular anomaly canceleation requirements in order to preserve renormalizability). But with GUT theories that "coincidence" is actually a consequence of the symmetries imposed on the theory by the GUT gauge interaction.

 Related Discussions Introductory Physics Homework 5 High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 2 Classical Physics 11 General Physics 6 Quantum Physics 22