The main difference between "Feynman" and "Resnick & Halliday" is their approach to teaching mechanics. Feynman's book is more conceptual and focuses on developing a deep understanding of the subject, while Resnick & Halliday's book is more mathematically rigorous and includes a larger number of practice problems.
This depends on the student's learning style and goals. If the student prefers a more conceptual approach and wants to develop a strong understanding of mechanics, then Feynman's book may be more suitable. However, if the student is looking for a more mathematically rigorous approach and wants to solve a large number of practice problems, then Resnick & Halliday's book may be a better choice.
Both books are designed for students at the 11th grade level, so some prior knowledge of physics is assumed. However, Feynman's book may be more accessible to students with limited knowledge of physics, as it focuses more on developing conceptual understanding rather than mathematical techniques.
Resnick & Halliday's book covers a wider range of topics in mechanics, including rotational motion, oscillations, and fluid mechanics. Feynman's book is more focused on the fundamentals of mechanics and may not cover as many advanced topics.
Both books follow a similar format, with clear explanations and illustrations followed by practice problems. However, Feynman's book also includes personal anecdotes and historical context, which may make the material more engaging for some students.