Gravity & Charge: Explained by Maxwell's Eqs?

In summary: The 'EM for gravity' crowd has not come up with a theory based on a Lagrangian and some field equations.
  • #1
GRDixon
249
0
All particles are charged, or consist of charged quarks whose total charges sum to zero. Therefore, all particles have internal electric fields, and charged particles also have external electric fields. The electric field is a form of energy. All energy engenders a gravitational field (or, if you prefer, warps flat space-time). Therefore gravity is explained, without exception, by Maxwell’s equations, right? Corollary: there is no such thing as matter.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
GRDixon said:
All particles are charged, or consist of charged quarks whose total charges sum to zero. Therefore, all particles have internal electric fields, and charged particles also have external electric fields. The electric field is a form of energy. All energy engenders a gravitational field (or, if you prefer, warps flat space-time). Therefore gravity is explained, without exception, by Maxwell’s equations, right? Corollary: there is no such thing as matter.
Neutrinos are fundamental and electrically neutral.
 
  • #3
GRDixon said:
All particles are charged, or consist of charged quarks whose total charges sum to zero. Therefore, all particles have internal electric fields, and charged particles also have external electric fields. The electric field is a form of energy. All energy engenders a gravitational field (or, if you prefer, warps flat space-time). Therefore gravity is explained, without exception, by Maxwell’s equations, right? Corollary: there is no such thing as matter.

Whether the statements in your a rgument are correct or not, your argument is of an invalid logical form.

Matheinste.
 
  • #4
Therefore gravity is explained, without exception, by Maxwell’s equations, right?
You're joking, aren't you ? I don't see anything that 'explains' gravity in Maxwell's equations.
 
  • #5
Remember: when all members register at Physics Forums, they agree to the Physics Forums Rules,

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=5374,

which, in part, state
Overly Speculative Posts: One of the main goals of PF is to help students learn the current status of physics as practiced by the scientific community; accordingly, Physicsforums.com strives to maintain high standards of academic integrity. There are many open questions in physics, and we welcome discussion on those subjects provided the discussion remains intellectually sound. It is against our Posting Guidelines to discuss, in most of the PF forums or in blogs, new or non-mainstream theories or ideas that have not been published in professional peer-reviewed journals or are not part of current professional mainstream scientific discussion.
 
  • #6
Mentz114 said:
You're joking, aren't you ? I don't see anything that 'explains' gravity in Maxwell's equations.

He's not, look at his blog, at the link with the "Maxwell Society".
 
  • #7
Uh... no... all you've explained is that some of the mass of a composite particle is due to the interaction energy of its constituent particles.

That has nothing to do with gravity.
 
  • #8
starthaus said:
He's not, look at his blog, at the link with the "Maxwell Society".

It wouldn't be so bad if the 'EM for gravity' crowd actually came up with a theory based on a Lagrangian and some field equations but I've never seen one.
 

1. What is Maxwell's Equations?

Maxwell's Equations are a set of four fundamental equations in electromagnetism that describe the relationship between electric and magnetic fields, and how they are affected by charges and currents.

2. How do Maxwell's Equations explain gravity?

Maxwell's Equations do not directly explain gravity, as they only describe the behavior of electric and magnetic fields. However, they are important in understanding how electric and magnetic fields interact with matter, which can then be applied to understanding gravity at a larger scale.

3. What is the relationship between charge and gravity?

Charge and gravity are two separate fundamental forces in the universe. Charge is the force that causes particles to interact with each other through electric and magnetic fields, while gravity is the force that causes objects with mass to attract each other. There is no direct relationship between the two, but they can both be described and understood through mathematical equations.

4. Why is Maxwell's Equations important in understanding electromagnetism?

Maxwell's Equations are important because they provide a comprehensive and mathematically rigorous framework for understanding the behavior of electric and magnetic fields. They have been used to predict and explain a wide range of electromagnetic phenomena, from the behavior of light to the functioning of electronic devices.

5. How have Maxwell's Equations been verified and tested?

Maxwell's Equations have been extensively tested and verified through experiments, observations, and mathematical calculations. Some of the most famous experiments that have confirmed the accuracy of these equations include the Michelson-Morley experiment, which demonstrated the existence of the speed of light, and the discovery of electromagnetic waves by Heinrich Hertz. Additionally, the equations have also been used to make accurate predictions about the behavior of electromagnetic fields in various situations.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
937
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
5
Views
446
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
699
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
789
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
42
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
13
Views
1K
Back
Top