
#1
Aug1913, 01:22 PM

P: 1

I wanted to ask how come kepler say that the orbits on which planet rotates is elliptical .... just by obvious saying, what we have learnt is that when the velocity is Perpendicular to force the path traced is circular.....even if we say in reality the actual angle B/W velocity and force is not 90 ....but i question is what makes a planet to go that far from the focci ? try to give an answer easy to understand. or please try to explain the mathematical proof in detail.




#2
Aug1913, 01:59 PM

Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 38,900

That's a very strange question!
It is not a matter of something "forcing" a planet to move in a noncircular orbit. It is a matter of there not being anything to force the planet to go in a circular orbit! A circular orbit has "eccentricity" exactly equal to 0. An elliptic orbit can have eccentricity anywhere from 0 to 1. It would be very surprising if a parameter were exactly 0 rather than some range of values. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Kepler's First Law  Classical Physics  7  
Kepler's 2nd Law Proof?  Classical Physics  3  
Kepler's law  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
kepler's law i think. I need help  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
Kepler's third law help.  Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework  11 