Register to reply

Don't understand what is exchanging with what in this acid/base equili

by alex_alex
Tags: acid base, equilibrium
Share this thread:
alex_alex
#1
Apr8-14, 01:42 PM
P: 2
NH4+ + H2O (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H3O+;

the same reaction can be written as:
NH4+ + HO- (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H2O;

where (kf) - rate of forward reaction and (kr) - rate of reverse reaction.

1 Question. NH4+ or NH3 exchanging with H2O?

If NH4+ is exchanging with H2O:
NH4+ (k-1) =(k1) H2O,

where (k1) - rate of exchange from NH4+ to H2O and (k-1) - rate of exchange from H2O to NH4+.


If NH3is exchanging with H2O:
NH3(k-1) =(k1) H2O,

where (k1) - rate of exchange from NH3 to H2O and (k-1) - rate of exchange from H2O to NH3.

2 Question. What is the relationship between k1, k-1 and kf, kr?
Phys.Org News Partner Chemistry news on Phys.org
Chemical biologists find new halogenation enzyme
Protein secrets of Ebola virus
Protein courtship revealed through chemist's lens
Borek
#2
Apr8-14, 02:28 PM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 23,716
Quote Quote by alex_alex View Post
NH4+ + H2O (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H3O+;

the same reaction can be written as:
NH4+ + HO- (kr) = (kf) NH3 + H2O;
I don't see why you assume it is the same reaction with the same rate constants. They are definitely related to the same equilibrium, but that's all.
alex_alex
#3
Apr8-14, 02:35 PM
P: 2
Quote Quote by Borek View Post
I don't see why you assume it is the same reaction with the same rate constants. They are definitely related to the same equilibrium, but that's all.
At pH=7, I assume that 1st one is the most likely case. I am not sure I understand NH4+ or NH3 is exchanging H+ with H2O?

Borek
#4
Apr8-14, 02:47 PM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 23,716
Don't understand what is exchanging with what in this acid/base equili

To be honest, I have no idea what the exact mechanism is - at the same time I don't think it matters. Equilibrium doesn't depend on these details, and it is equilibrium that we are typically interested in.

Please note there is no such thing as H+ nor OH- in the solution. H3O+ is only an approximation, as proton is most likely solvated by more than one water molecule. OH- is solvated as well, so it is present as - at least - H3O2-. We ignore all these and it doesn't interfere with our understanding of acid/base reactions, why should it matter for ammonia?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
The weak acid conjugate base - something i can't understand. Chemistry 4
Find the molecular mass of acid in acid base neutralization Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 6
Acid-Base Titrations - Soda Lime and Hydrochloric Acid Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 7
Weak acid/strong base titration (Acetic acid/NaOH) Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 4
Titrating weak acid buffer with strong acid after the base is used up Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 6